Review: The Girl on the Train (New Victoria)

By Alex Roy

Rating: 5 out of 5.

This week, The Girl on the Train has pulled into Woking’s New Victoria Theatre. Adapted from Paula Hawkins’ bestselling novel, this psychological thriller is more than a mere ‘whodunnit’. It is a haunting meditation on perception, memory, and the uncomfortable greyness of human morality, highlighting blurred lines between victim and perpetrator, truth and self-deception. Buckle up; this thriller is full steam ahead.

At the heart of this story is Rachel Watson – an alcoholic, and self-confessed “unreliable narrator” who watches life pass her by through the window of her daily train commute. Each morning she observes the same couple living a life she aches to experience: one of unbridled love. However, when the woman she has been watching each day goes missing, Rachel goes from mere observer to prime suspect in the unraveling investigation, as she is forced to confront her own darkness while piecing together the story of the missing girl.

“There is no dramatic irony, or convoluted overlapping timelines: instead, the mystery unfolds in real time, leaving us just as disoriented and desperate for answers as Rachel is”

There is always something fascinating about watching stories shift from page to the silver screen to stage. Too often, theatrical adaptations lean too heavily on their source material, resulting in a story that fails to stand alone. The Girl on the Train does not make this mistake. I entered the New Victoria Theatre with zero knowledge of the novel or the film, but left utterly engrossed and itching to read the original. In this stage adaptation, the narrative is anchored entirely from Rachel’s perspective: we only ever see what she sees, learn what she learns, and speak to whom she speaks. There is no dramatic irony, or convoluted overlapping timelines: instead, the mystery unfolds in real time, leaving us just as disoriented and desperate for answers as Rachel is. It is this direct alignment with her perspective that creates such a potent sense of immersion.

This show demands – from each and every performer – a rawness that feels almost intrusive. The cast delivered impeccably – all gut-wrenching in their honesty and restraint. Louisa Lytton, taking on the role of Rachel, gave a gutturally flawless performance. Known primarily for her work on screen in EastEnders and The Bill, it is not a given that such success will translate on stage, but for Lytton, it absolutely does. Her portrayal was impeccable, navigating chaos and control, confusion and clarity, and self-loathing and determination in a way that never feels forced – it was truly breathtaking.

Samuel Collings as Scott Hipwell delivers a quietly devastating performance. His portrayal of a man undone by grief and masculine fragility brought genuine tears to my eyes. Paul McEwan as D.I Gaskill was an unexpected delight – his dry wit and grounded presence offer much-needed levity throughout, while simultaneously conveying the weariness of a tired investigator. Jason Merrells as Tom Watson is equally as enthralling, oscillating between charm and moral ambiguity. His versatility in this role is staggering; neither the audience nor characters on stage ever quite know where they stand with him, something testament to his strength as a performer.

“In her world, there is no set to hide behind, nothing to distract: just people breaking apart and holding on in real time”

It was the creative choices of this play however that truly bolstered its strength, with the utilisation of minimalism in particular – through set (Adam Wiltshire), lighting (Jack Knowles) and costume (Adam Wiltshire) – not only to adapt for the logistics of touring, but also as a means of psychological focus. The stage is bare, aside from an unmade bed and a few LED panels that both denote location and actualise mental states. Even before the show commences, the unmade bed is held in a cold, stark spotlight. It is Rachel’s world – the mess, the solitude, the haunting weight of her reality – laid bare for all to see. In her world, there is no set to hide behind, nothing to distract: just people breaking apart and holding on in real time.

The lighting design in particular deserves its own applause. Cold and clinical throughout, it traps characters on stage in pools of exposure. Rachel is constantly illuminated and rarely afforded the comfort of shadow. In the final scene, however, as some semblance of resolution sets in, the once harsh light is replaced by a soft, golden warmth. This shift prompted a shared, almost instinctive exhale from the audience – and in that collective sigh of relief, I realised just how tightly the play had gripped me. It hadn’t let go.

The Girl on the Train is a gripping, gritty, gorgeously executed thriller that, in even its quietest moments, says the loudest things about what it means to be human. Leaving space for discomfort, empathy, and raw humanity. It is a production that confronts darkness; it doesn’t let you sit back passively. That is precisely what makes it so powerful.

The Girl on the Train is running at the New Victoria Theatre in Woking until Saturday 26th April. Get your tickets here.

Image Credit: Pamela Raith