Review: The Caucasian Chalk Circle

cauk

By Lily James

Entering into the Assembly Rooms to find the actors chatting, draped over the audience’s seats, (acting as actors not acting), is a supremely ballsy start to Ethrael Theatre’s Caucasian Chalk Circle.

The director’s note, insisting that we should ‘not compare this play to what you many be accustomed to’ serves to intimidate a newcomer to Brecht rather than illuminate. This slightly defensive stance feels unnecessary, as it is the force of this production’s ambition that sustains the performance, and its boldest moments are its greatest successes.

Mylonadis is a director with obvious talent and flair. The use of chalk to create imaginary spaces on stage; rivers, houses, and a background of mountain towns, never feels gimmicky. Instead, it contributes to the sense of artificiality, by which the audience is encouraged to engage, but never to invest too much in the action on stage.

The styling of the piece is at its best when at its most irreverent; the leather clad Corporal, wielding a phallic lance, and Yussup in the tub, shower cap perched jauntily on his head, both stand out as moments of visual creativity and wit. Sam McKay’s puppet of Michael was oddly emotive, successfully creating a tension between what the audience knew was fake and what we wanted to see.

The songs were performed by Rob Collins, who had the commanding stage presence necessary to make him feel like a performer in his own right, rather than an accompaniment to the main action.

It was unfortunate that when other actors took to the mic, they were at times overpowered by the sound of the band, meaning some of the lyrics went unheard. Despite this, the interplay between Collins himself and the other actors was fantastic, particularly in his narration of Grusha and Simon Chachava’s unsaid words.

While the overarching themes of the play are handled with remarkable confidence, the specifics of the performance suffered through a lack of polish. Spaces were drawn then not adhered to; a chalk square would be marked out to represent a house, then whoever was inside it pushed through the imagined wall.  Regional accents were at times unforgivably sloppy, veering from Welsh to West Country then back to the actor’s own accent. The stretch of playing multiple roles occasionally led to a real lack of differentiation between each character played by the same actor; each hunchbacked peasant eventually blurred into one.

However, both Ellie Bowness and Carrie Gaunt must be praised for their total commitment to the different parts they played, both actors giving each of their varied roles a distinct physicality and characterisation. Brilliance also came in flashes from other ensemble members: Dominic McGovern, as the brilliantly nasty Yussup, and Jenny Hudec, as his equally awful mother, were a blackly comic double act.

Pegah Moradi’s Grusha is both resilient yet tender, Moradi never allowing her performance to become sentimental. Her ability to create a convincing relationship between herself and Michael, too, is commendable. Harvey Comerford makes a hugely charismatic Azdak, engaging as both a singer and an actor. His malapropisms and dubious morality are played in a way that is extremely entertaining without ever veering into pantomime.

As an introduction to Modernist theatre, I recommend this production highly. It’s not going to be to the taste of devotees of realist theatre, but then, it doesn’t want or try to be. The cast and production team have in a short space of time created something that feels truly inventive, and is well worth seeing for anyone who wants to expand and question their understanding of theatre.

 

Image: Sofia Greaves.