Review: Sick Dog (Fourth Wall)

By Beth Dench

★★★★★

Relationships, AI, Death and… Love Island? These are only a couple of the themes explored in student-written Sick Dog by Maariya Khalid: the exploration of a relationship between an AI care-giving robot Eliza and her dying patient Winne. Witty, thought-provoking, and existential, this piece of student theatre is a credit to Durham’s Fourth Wall Theatre Company by the range of relevant questions explored within the piece – such as could today’s evolving digitalisation of AI encourage a more intimate relationship between humans and our digital programmes? By the end of the piece, it did make me wonder which character really was the human and who was the humanoid? What does it mean to really feel when you are alive? 

Maariya Khalid’s writing is captivating

Maariya Khalid’s writing is captivating, pulling on stimulating concepts looking at connection, digitalisation, dehumanisation, humanisation, love, and death. The writer tackles and embeds a lot of meaning in every scene and has curated emotional in-depth characters, who tackle a serious of culturally relevant topics from ideas about love, God, what happens if our life amounts to the amount of Love Island we watch, and who really is the “nicest looking boy” – Idris Elba? Personally, I loved this writers’ stylistic exploration of love and relationships, pulling on the subtle and simple acts of love and care, evident in the story-line that felt like the audience was involved in a long debrief between two friends. The use of the stage space from the brilliant direction of Billie Switonski added to this intimate environment; full of the little ways love can be executed, from the cleaning of dishes, small shoulder kisses, child-like food fights and just being there. 

The play was set in a small flat, filled with dishes, dirty clothes and miscellaneous house equipment (one could say very well-lived in), light up by clinical and opposing pink intimate lighting. These two simple lights seem like very niche thing to draw upon, but I really loved the ambience the light design created to show important moments within piece; acting as the juxtaposing moods the different characters brought to the living space. Eliza symbolising this warm and nurturing pink atmosphere juxtaposed by Winnie’s blue aura, conveying her cold attitude to her current health status and life. Gemma Parker did an excellent job in designing this space for the story to be realised, with minimal sound to pull the audience’s attention into the story. 

Pearl D’Souza’s loveable, empathetic and robotic character of Eliza, was easy to find comfort in

Pearl D’Souza’s loveable, empathetic and robotic character of Eliza, was easy to find comfort in; directly contrasting with Winnie’s constant antagonism. I was thoroughly impressed by D’souza’s embodiment of the AI humanoid robot – her voice never flinched from this monotonal, Siri-like caricature. It reminded me of a feminised version of the Disney character Baymax, through her comedic naivety to the world unprogrammed in her hardwire, docile personality, and attentiveness to her patient Winnie. Furthermore, her physicality, applaudably took on this mechanical actualisation – her eyes creepily blinking into the audience and sharpish gestures around the stage space – was admirable. However, physically, I would have liked it to have been more exaggerated for a more believable persona, yet, generally speaking, this actor is faultless.

Cara Crofts played the less loveable, nihilistic and hostile character of Winnie. Crofts certainly embodied this desolate character who was fed up with the world around her – from God and boyfriends – she clearly found no happiness in her real-life relationships or life. I was sceptical at first to see how Crofts would take on such an emotionally heavy character and have mixed reviews about the execution. At certain points I found the actor’s choices rather anti-climactic and confusing due to her lethargic and isolated stage presence. However, I cannot decide whether or not it worked to convey the nihilistic mindset of Winnie. That being said, the actor’s emotional vulnerability on stage must be noted as admirable, from emotional outbursts to playful witty comments, grand and soulful, philosophical statements and childlike mannerisms. The actor had a lot of range to work with. Given time to develop, Winnie had the potential to be a really strong character. 

Personally, I do wish the performance was more fast-paced, as I felt the dragged-out moments did not aid the development of the production, or encourage the chemistry to grow on stage. I did find the more direct intimacy between Winne and Eliza, very unexpected as the acting on stage did not grow enough to make this change in relationship status comprehendible from an audience perspective. The caring personality of Eliza implied love inevitability (“I was made for you,” “I wish you had more time”, “I feel really, really”), however Winnie seemed too drawn out in her own antipathy, past relationships and sickness to even aid the idea of wanting to be intimate with a robot. 

Overall though an amazing piece of student-theatre, with lots of potential. I cannot wait to see what Khalid comes up with next!

Sick Dog, produced by Fourth Wall, was in performance at the City Theatre, Durham from 4 – 5 March 2025. This was part of a double bill with I CANT STOP THE LONELINESS produced by Rocket Theatre.

Image Credit: Iris Varla