Review: Sherlock Holmes

sherlock

Sadie Kempner reviews the Woodplayers Theatre Company’s offering of Sherlock Holmes, and is generally impressed by the performance. 

Sherlock Holmes, in book, film or theatre form, is an absolute favourite of mine; a fact of which I was terribly aware when entering the Collingwood College dining hall to watch the Woodplayers Theatre Company’s newest production. I was, on the whole, impressed by their interpretation of such an iconic piece.

Their choice of script was interesting; an adaptation of William Gillette’s 1899 play ‘Sherlock Holmes: A Drama in Four Acts (as we were there for two and a half hours and not four I assume it was greatly adapted…) uses a combination of Holmes classics including A Study in Scarlett, A Scandal in Bohemia and The Final Problem as well as much new material. As the adaptation had cut a fair amount of the original text however, some of the plot got a little bit lost, particularly with regards to Holmes’ love interest.

It was a lovely touch to have the familiar music used in Sherlock and the Robert Downey Jr. Sherlock Holmes films playing as the audience were taking their seats; it definitely helped to set the tone for what was certainly a very well put together piece.

Andy White gave a nearly faultless performance as Sherlock Holmes, capturing perfectly the arrogant genius that we all know and love about the character. White seemed to have no problem with the incredibly wordy text and the audience felt comfortable that he knew what he was doing and led the scene effortlessly. His interaction with his fellow actors was consistently strong and relationships were clear; this was particularly important with a female Watson there was potential to lose something of the chumminess that is so loved about their relationship. My only criticism of White would be that in being so effortless with his characterisation, the audience sometimes lost some of what he was trying to say in his just off Cumberbatch-style diction.

Jess Hey’s Watson was equally masterful. Not only was she authoritative and serious as a doctor, but she also handled the back and forth duologues with Holmes wonderfully. She seemed to fully occupy her role and really engaged with the rest of the action in a very naturalistic way.

Solid performances were given by Anna Chambers and Nick Yeates as Madge and James Larrabee (the vaguely misguided villains of the mystery) who handled a lot of dialogue very smoothly, although the first scene particularly was unnecessarily shouty and very fast (this may have been down pre-show adrenaline however as they both improved throughout the performance). Anna Galbraith should also be commended, as her ‘Billy’ was not only charming and funny, but also seemed to come to her with an authenticity that was just a joy to watch.

I was less confident in the directorial decision to have a female Moriarty. Jessie Smith’s portrayal of this super-villain was very strong and confident; however I did want her to be more threatening and intimidating as some of her most dramatic moments were dampened somewhat by a more petulant approach. Even though she was a very strong character it didn’t always feel like she was in control of her scenes.

Unfortunately, I also felt Shannon Burke’s Alice Faulkner (Sherlock’s love interest) left a little to be desired. While her speech, physicality and confidence were all very good, she didn’t inspire a huge amount of warmth in the audience despite playing a sympathetic character. This made her romance with Sherlock even more confusing as the audience never quite understood what her intentions were.

Aside from this, the look of the piece overall was very impressive; Alisha Hallwood’s costume design was absolutely perfect for the period and she was very consistent in the style she was going for. It’s very easy to be lazy with time periods and make everything pre-1920 “old fashioned” but Hallwood had wonderful attention to detail particularly with the women’s costumes.

Overall, the audience left the performance feeling thoroughly entertained. A very strong cast gave their all in what was always an ambitious piece and the result was slick and polished.

 

 

Photograph: Osha Al