Review: Private Lives at the Gielgud Theatre

By Lucy Spoliar 

Harriet-Jade Harrow

As a great devotee of Noel Coward’s Private Lives, I approached viewing a third production with some trepidation.

For, while the sharp wit of Coward’s writing is beyond question, there remains a risk that the one-liners in a play written eighty-three years ago may feel dated.

However, I need not have worried; Jonathan Kent’s production is without a doubt the best that I have seen. So much so that I would greatly enjoy watching the same production for a second (or even a third) time.

The play follows the story of Elyot and Amanda, a divorced couple who find themselves in neighbouring rooms in the same hotel, both honeymooning with their new spouses.

Chaos ensues as by the end of the first Act, the two have eloped together to Paris, unable to resist their feelings for one another.

The key to the success of this production is the electric raw chemistry between Toby Stephens (Elyot) and Anna Chancellor (Amanda).

In the first Act, Kent’s production effectively underlines the stark contrast between Anna-Louise Plowman’s whining Sibyl and Chancellor’s independent and sophisticated Amanda.

As soon as Elyot appears on the scene, brilliantly portrayed by Stephens as a moody, childish figure who has little patience for Sibyl’s clingy affection, it is obvious that they are very ill-matched.

By contrast, Stephens and Chancellor create an irresistibly powerful sense of familiarity between their two characters, leaving the audience with the impression that it is somehow natural and inevitable that the two of them should elope.

Furthermore, Chancellor and Stephens bring to life the immaturity of their characters so effectively that the audience is caught up in the farcical nature of the situation and is unable to distinguish conventional ideas of morality from the more appealing, exciting chemistry between the two lovers.

By causing audience members to react in this manner, this production successfully encompasses what was perhaps one of Coward’s principal intentions in writing the play.

However, I would argue that what really sets this production apart from others is the emotional depth Chancellor and Stephens bring to their parts.

As Amanda, Chancellor carries off a fine balance between glamour and insecurity, stemming from an awareness that she is older than she was when she and Elyot were first together.

Stephens, for his part, fearlessly portrays the darker, more unpleasant side to his character in his acts of domestic violence towards Amanda and his cruel scorn of Sybil.

The venom with which Stephens delivers the line “I should like to cut off your head with a meat axe” to Sybil in the first Act, goes beyond the comedic and makes his character appear truly frightening.

If I had to raise one criticism against the production, I would argue that Anthony Calf and Anna-Louise Plowman, as Victor (Amanda’s dull, middle-aged second husband) and Sybil, are unable to bring any great interest or novelty to their characters.

However, Coward himself described Victor and Sybil as “extra puppets, lightly wooden ninepins” so this is perhaps not surprising.

The fact remains that this is an absolutely superb production, which brings to life a classic in a new and memorable way.

Illustration: Harriet-Jade Harrow