Review: nativity! the musical
By Alex Roy
Bursting with charm, humour and festive cheer, Pick Me Up Theatre’s Nativity! The Musical is the epitome of Christmas joy. This vibrant adaptation of the beloved 2009 film remains faithful to the original story while introducing inventive staging, new songs, and plenty of theatrical magic that perfectly embodies the season’s spirit.
The show mirrors the storyline of the film: Mr Maddens (Alex Hogg), a teacher at St Bernadette’s primary school, finds himself caught in a rivalry with Gordon Shakespeare (Jonny Holbek) – his ex-friend and uptight teacher at the local private school Oakmoor. Determined to gain a five-star review, outdoing Shakespeare in the annual nativity play, Mr Maddens falls into a web of lies, claiming that Hollywood producers are coming to turn their performance into a movie. As Coventry buzzes with excitement, chaotic hilarity ensues, and Mr Maddens is forced to embark on a trip to LA in an attempt to make his lie a reality.

From the get-go, the set design (Robert Readman) was a standout feature of the production, vividly bringing the world of Nativity! to life. From the anticipated festive touches of Christmas trees, presents, stars, and snow, to the more ingenious blow-up aeroplane, and Mr Poppy’s (Adam Sowter) scooter, the set and prop design aided the vibrancy of the production. However, the use of more subtle props (Jane and Teresa Carr) truly tied the story together. One of these, at the beginning of Act One, was the use of letter blocks (reminiscent of large scrabble pieces). These highlighted the educational disparity between St Bernadette’s and Oakmoor, whilst evoking laughs from the audience, amidst a song reminiscent of ‘School Song’ from Matilda The Musical. This spelling motif continued throughout, with Mr Poppy’s tinsel-covered clothes rail being labelled ‘ORDISHUNS’, providing yet another inventive, laugh-out-loud moment, upholding the humorous heart of the show.
“He had the audience laughing, cheering and totally swept up in the festive spirit”
This production is brought to life by the cast: the heart of it being Adam Sowter’s portrayal of Mr Poppy, the excitable classroom assistant. Sowter’s performance was magical, capturing the essence of Mr Poppy with uncanny accuracy while bringing a spark to the role. Brimming with enthusiasm, he lit up each scene with his childlike wonder and unrestrained energy. He had the audience laughing, cheering and totally swept up in the festive spirit, as he balanced humour with genuine warmth, giving the character of Mr Poppy a heart amidst the show’s chaos.
Equally compelling was Jonny Holbek as Gordon Shakespeare, skilfully embodying the comedic villain with theatrical flair. His exaggerated mannerisms and pompous attitude elicited boos from the audience, a testament to his success in bringing this dislikable character to life. Towards the end of the show, much of his role is brought to the level of the audience in the stalls, such that it becomes an interactive performance, reminiscent of a pantomime. This further propels the festive feel, but I would have loved to see the big ‘sabotage’ moment take centre stage – there is a possibility it was lost amidst the chaos for those sitting out of his eyeline.
“The children were remarkable in their abilities to throw themselves into this performance with such confidence”
Through careful direction (Lesley Lettin), the production successfully achieved a distinct visual contrast between the two schools – something arguably difficult to achieve whilst working with children in a live production. St Bernadette’s had a charming scruffiness, reflected in their slightly disorganised movements, and heartfelt interactions between the children. Oakmoor, on the other hand, remained prim and regimented, with a lack of interaction further perpetuating this, enhanced by their green sweater vests and berets, adding to their over-polished image. The children were remarkable in their abilities to throw themselves into this performance with such confidence. They effortlessly worked with the material to breathe life into this adaptation of Nativity!, doing it justice whilst enhancing the humour and heart with their charm. With incredible professionalism, they attacked the choreography with energy and polish, bringing a smile to the face of every single person in the audience.

The lighting design seamlessly supported the narrative, both enhancing emotional beats and adding festive sparkle. However, it was the use of darkness that was especially evocative. From Mr Maddens’ unlit Christmas tree, symbolising his heartbreak, to the final ‘sabotage’ scene leaving the entire auditorium in darkness. This gave rise to an interactive element of the show, with audience members encouraged to use their phone flashlights to light the stage, breaking the fourth wall to provide an air of intimacy.
“The costumes of the children brought a burst of colour to the stage, underpinning the joy that ricocheted through the theatre”
Costume design (Laura Heward) added another layer of clever storytelling, with each costume delightfully propelling the characterisation of each individual. Mr Poppy, for example, wore bright yellow and green throughout, standing in stark contrast with Mr Maddens’ monochromatic look, mirroring both their differing personalities and their attitudes to Christmas. The costumes of the children brought a burst of colour to the stage, underpinning the joy that ricocheted through the theatre. The final nativity costumes were incredible and rich equally with colour, texture, and character.

Though geared towards families, Isitt and Ager’s book worked to delight adults, with subtle jokes woven throughout. From small references to 50 Shades of Grey, alongside the modernisation of the show with nods to the King, Ant and Dec, the ‘floss’, and several gags worthy of the laughs they evoked from all the audience. They were integrated cleverly, such that they went over the heads of the youngsters in the audience, thus failing to tarnish the ‘family’ nature of the show.
Pick Me Up Theatre delivered a production of Nativity! The Musical, packed full of heart, humour and holiday spirit. It captured the essence of Christmas in a way that left the audience, laughing, clapping, and ready to ‘Deck the Halls’.
Nativity! The Musical is in performance at the Grand Opera House, York until 30 November. Tickets are available here.
Image Credit: Lotty Farmer

