Review: Murder Mystery at Durham Castle

By Ellen Orange

Nicola Todhunter

Lingering in the World Heritage Visitor Centre, I had no idea what to expect from Castle Theatre Company’s Murder Mystery.

As the play begins, the audience is addressed by Cartwright the butler, informing us that as we are guests to Lady Dunelm’s dinner party, he will escort us in and be our guide throughout the evening, immediately absorbing us into the play.

We are escorted up to a part of the castle in which we stumble upon characters engaged in conversation, and so the context and subsequently the events begin to unfold.

The play continues with us, as the family’s ‘guests’ being escorted from room to room by Cartwright, played by Michael Earnshaw, who calmly orchestrates the action and smoothly organises us guests, while also becoming primary investigator.

Guided round to watch the events unravel, we walk into a sumptuous dining room, full of decadence with characters in black tie accompanied by glasses of wine, setting the scene of an aristocratic dinner party.

The characters look the part in glamorous dresses, neat hair, and make-up.

We are warmly greeted by an exuberant Lady Dunelm, portrayed by Lily Drake, and we proceed to watch characters move about us, engaging with each other and we come to ‘overhear’ their conversations.

Eventually, we hear the shrill scream of a distraught Lady Dunelm, the murder has occurred and we must find out who the culprit is.

Her son Richard has been stabbed in the back, and while the devastated Lady Dunelm breaks down, Cartwright takes control by interrogating the family and guests.

We see a passionate display from Lily Drake, while Izzie Price, playing her daughter Maria, trembles with shock as she apologies to the guests and tries to maintain decorum.

Likewise, Fleur Manning, as Mrs Dunwell attempts to regain composure and help Cartwright in his task.

Cressida Peever’s story is a classic murder mystery in the style of Agatha Christie; we watch the characters as they accuse and point fingers, defend themselves or others, deduce possible events, and reveal their secrets and motivations.

The narrative is carefully constructed to explain and justify the events, and also to factor in the ‘guests.’

Halfway through the show we are informed dinner has been spoiled but as the evening has been taxing, we are invited to partake in refreshments and so are directed into a room for wine and nibbles during this ‘interval.’

The play is embedded in aristocratic tradition, which Nick Owen passionately reinforces as Lord Harwood, and he comes to be pitted against the poor Jacob, who Alex Prescott intelligently portrays in his meditations on theatre in relation to human nature and murderous instinct.

Equally, we have the arrogant John, charismatically played by David Myers, caught in a scandal involving Annie the maid, whose bitterness Pippa Mosely portrays with great energy and feeling.

Admittedly the ending of the play does not come as a surprise, but if anything it cements the story even more firmly as a classic murder mystery we know what the other characters have to investigate for themselves.

And equally, being incorporated into the play itself gives us a whole new take on events, as we are physically present and involved when the characters reveal their secrets or confess their misdemeanours.

At times it seemed stilted. Shuffling a group of people from room to room is not always so smooth, and stood in rooms and corridors we did not always get the best view of all the action or hear all of the dialogue.

But these are minor issues which, if anything, add a more realistic element to the drama.

For what I would have thought to have been a staging nightmare for director Chris Blois-Brooke, the cast pulled it off brilliantly, with the characters successfully manoeuvring their way around the audience and politely excusing themselves for it if we happened to be in the way.

Considering how difficult this must have been to put into practice, I think the cast should be congratulated for their success.

The format serves to increase our intrigue, the suspense builds as we are led back and forth, following characters, seeing parts of the events, and I found myself immersed in the events, even being led to wonder what was transpiring between the characters we had just left.

All in all I can say it was an original and thoroughly enjoyable experience. My only regret is that I wasn’t able to attend the black tie showing on Sunday, as I feel this would add even further to the realism of being involved.

As a classic whodunit with an innovative twist, I highly recommend getting over to the castle for Lady Dunelm’s dinner party.

Photograph: Nicola Todhunter