Review: John Proctor is the Villain (Royal Court)

By Tori Travers

Rating: 5 out of 5.

Only one production has ended with me immediately on my feet. Last Tuesday, Kimberly Belflower’s John Proctor is the Villain became the second. Granted, I do not believe theatre ought to leave one endlessly turning it over afterwards to be successful, but that is exactly what this play did. I thought about it on the train home, the next morning, then a week later, until even my friends asked me to stop bringing it up.

Its force lies not only in what it says about power, feminism and harm, but in who it seems to be speaking to. So many works about women, even feminist ones, still feel angled towards persuasion: explaining female anger, justifying female pain, making women’s experiences legible to those least inclined to believe them. John Proctor is the Villain feels different; it does not ask its girls to make themselves palatable. For the first time in my life, I watched a play that did not circle young women, translate us, or leave us looking in through a window. It addressed us directly, unashamedly, almost celebratorily — and I was startled by the force of realising that, for once, I was the intended audience.

It is funny, furious, deeply specific, and painfully recognisable

John Proctor is the Villain is a modern response to The Crucible. Its British debut at the Royal Court Theatre feels especially apt, given that The Crucible also had its British premiere there. Set in 2018 in a rural Georgia high school, the play follows a group of students as they study Arthur Miller’s text while their own lives begin to echo, distort and challenge the play in front of them. But to call it a retelling would be slightly misleading. Belflower is not simply updating The Crucible for a contemporary audience. Instead, she interrogates its moral inheritance: why John Proctor has so often been treated as a tragic hero, why young women’s anger is so easily dismissed as hysteria, and why stories about male reputation so often take precedence over stories about female harm. Crucially, the play does not need to make Miller’s John Proctor less morally ambiguous in order to challenge his cultural afterlife.

The play’s language is one of its greatest strengths, though also perhaps its most obvious limitation. It is steeped in late-2010s pop culture: Lorde’s Melodrama, Taylor Swift, Selena Gomez, Beyoncé, The Great Gatsby, and the wider atmosphere of #MeToo-era feminism and the American political landscape. These references are not decorative, they form part of the play’s emotional and intellectual architecture, used by the girls as a shared archive of feeling, evidence, warning signs and half-understood politics. Crucially, they also mirror both The Crucible and the inner workings of John Proctor is the Villain itself. That specificity gives the writing a generational texture that a more generalised feminist drama might lack, though some of its intelligence risks being lost on the wrong audience. Still, I am not sure the play would be better without it. The references are part of the point: they show how young women build moral frameworks out of the materials available to them, songs, celebrity narratives, classroom texts, gossip, news stories, and the things adults say without realising they are being listened to. The play may not be timeless in the traditional sense, but that does not weaken it. If anything, it makes it hit harder.

The play may not be timeless in the traditional sense, but that does not weaken it. If anything, it makes it hit harder

The music sharpens that effect. Rather than feeling like a playlist dropped onto the production for easy recognition, the songs become part of the play’s own language. From the moment you walk in, the pre-show music prepares you for the characters’ world. The songs themselves are deliberately chosen: ‘If I Were a Boy’, ‘Dancing on My Own’, ‘Bad Liar’, and, most notably, Lorde’s ‘Team’. Curated by Palmer Hefferan, the playlist locates the girls in a very specific generational world, where music is not just entertainment but confession, evidence, community and release.

The production’s design also deserves praise. Set entirely in a classroom, the staging makes strong use of a contained space: desks, routines, and the who sits where all become part of the girls’ social world. The room feels recognisable enough to be funny but restricted enough to become claustrophobic as the play progresses. Even the two doors, through which we occasionally glimpse the corridor outside, are used carefully, creating a strange tension around whether the girls are ever truly private. Most strikingly, the classroom belongs to Mr Carter Smith, the play’s Proctor figure. When he writes his name on the board, and a strobe-like lighting effect later makes the white chalk flare against the blackboard, the set and lighting briefly make his authority feel almost physical. The design makes literal what the play is already exploring: the way male influence can structure a room even when men are not speaking.

The play has also been criticised for being didactic, and I understand why. There are moments when characters state the argument plainly; at times, the play does tell rather than show. But I found myself more forgiving of this than I expected, partly because its bluntest lines are often its most realistic. Phrases like “witch hunt” really were thrown around casually in 2018. When Smith says, “you’re one of the few friends I have left,” I have rarely heard an audience recoil so vocally. Around me were audible gasps, sharp intakes of breath, and the kind of collective wince that suggests a line landed somewhere uncomfortably familiar. Teenage conversations about feminism, assault and reputation are often direct and over-explained, because the people having them are still working out what they believe. More than that, there is something revealing in the discomfort of the play’s directness. Women are so often expected to make their pain less blunt, less angry, more palatable; yet the language used to dismiss, manipulate or disbelieve them is rarely softened in return. If Belflower’s dialogue sometimes feels too explicit, perhaps that is because the language directed at young women often is.

The design makes literal what the play is already exploring: the way male influence can structure a room even when men are not speaking

Crucially, though, the play is genuinely funny. The humour is allowed to breathe, which is part of why the heavier moments land so sharply. The direction and performances allow the audience to laugh at jokes that feel completely natural to teenage conversation: fast, self-aware, silly, cutting and affectionate all at once. All the actors shine in these humorous moments, and the playful dynamics between the girls are a particular highlight. Lauryn Ajufo is especially strong as Nell Shaw, a transfer student from Atlanta, bringing warmth, sharpness and impeccable comic timing.

The performances help sustain that truthfulness. The cast capture the volatility of teenage conversation: the speed, the humour, the sudden emotional turns, and the sense that everything is both a joke and deadly serious. There is a rough-and-ready quality to the production at times, including the occasional wobble in the American accents. But rather than distracting, this often enhances the feeling of teenagers straining under language too large for them.

Dónal Finn, as Mr Carter Smith, brings charm and unease in equal measure, making it easy to understand why the students are drawn to him before the play begins to reframe that intimacy. Sadie Soverall is equally strong as Shelby, the Abigail-esque figure whose mistakes and flaws precede her introduction, so that the audience initially encounters her through other people’s versions of her. This creates one of the production’s sharpest contrasts. Carter Smith begins admired and trusted before falling from grace; Shelby begins already judged, and has to fight her way back into being seen as a person.

Molly McFadden is also excellent as Miss Bailey Gallagher, one of the production’s most quietly interesting figures. Initially, Gallagher appears to occupy a familiar role: the stricter woman, the one who seems to hold the girls back while the male teacher gets to be charismatic and beloved. But the play gradually complicates that expectation. Near the conclusion, in an especially poignant scene between the two teachers, Gallagher plainly lays out her trust in Smith and the regret she now feels. McFadden gives her a contained fury that feels all the more powerful for not being theatricalised, while Finn masterfully shows the loss of the easy respect his character once held.

Ultimately, John Proctor is the Villain lands because it refuses to make its girls more palatable. It does not water down their language, their anger, their contradictions or their cultural references in order to persuade a sceptical audience more politely. Perhaps that means it will not work equally well for everyone. But I am not convinced it needs to. There is strength in a feminist play that is not primarily structured around making men understand women, but around allowing women, especially those who recognise the world it depicts, to feel the shock of recognition.

John Proctor is the Villain is currently in its sold-out run at the Royal Court before transferring to Wyndham’s Theatre in 2027. I would wholeheartedly recommend it, especially to those who recognise the culture it is speaking from. It is funny, furious, deeply specific, and painfully recognisable.

Image: Camilla Greenwell via Royal Court.