Review: Iolanthe

By Alex Roy

★★★★★

What happens when bureaucracy collides with the absurdity of fairy magic? Gilbert and Sullivan’s Iolanthe is the answer. Durham Opera Ensemble’s latest production seizes this wit, delivering a spectacle as ridiculous as it is enchanting. From pompous peers to ethereal fairies, each moment brimming with theatrical flair, underscored by an orchestra that brings the music to life. But in an operetta that demands both humour and heart, did the Durham Opera Ensemble strike the balance? I think they did.

Gilbert and Sullivan’s Iolanthe weaves political satire, fantasy, and romance into a sparkling operetta that is as witty as it is whimsical. At its heart is Strephon (Joseph Wilson), half-fairy, half-mortal caught between two worlds, whose love for the sought-after Phyllis (Mathilda Ketterer) is thrown into turmoil by a misunderstanding. Chaos ensues, the boundaries between logic and magic are blurred, and power, love and law are satirised with a lightness. This operetta proves that even the most absurd concepts can carry incredibly poignant truths.

From the moment I stepped into the Assembly Rooms, the air of enchantment was undeniable. Vines and flowers cascaded around the auditorium, blurring the line between human theatre and fairyland, drawing the audience into Iolanthe’s world before even a single note was played. As the overture played, this magic continued to permeate the space, as projected fairy dust (Sophia Christopherou and Ruby Huynh) danced across the closed curtain – a simple, yet mesmerising touch that set a whimsical tone for the evening.

Every member of the cast and band excelled, crafting a production as polished as it was playful

Durham Opera Ensemble’s decision to stage Iolanthe for their Epiphany Term production was both inspired and strategic – the perfect choice, if you will. Performed in English, and brimming with sharp comedy, the operetta provided an accessible yet musically demanding platform to showcase both the cast and the orchestra. The blend of opera, spoken dialogue and choreographed movement made for an engaging experience, drawing in seasoned opera-goers and newcomers alike. The brilliance of Gilbert’s libretto ensured a lively reception, with the audience caught constantly between laughter and admiration – proof of both the piece’s enduring wit, and the DOE’s excellent execution.

A strong libretto is one thing, but without sharp execution, even the wittiest operetta can fall flat. Fortunately, Durham Opera Ensemble’s Iolanthe suffered no such fate. Every member of the cast and band excelled, crafting a production as polished as it was playful. Daniel Hicks’ performance as Lord Chancellor was perhaps the highlight of the evening. His sharp, comedic instincts and meticulous physicality – particularly in Love Unrequited – elevated the role’s absurdity to perfection. Mathilda Ketterer’s Phyllis was equally compelling, her astounding vocals matched by a performance that was both charming and convincing. Her chemistry with Joseph Wilson’s Strephon further strengthened the emotional core of the piece. Maia Harris Lindop shone as the Fairy Queen, effortlessly wielding both the character’s comedic and commanding presence, while Ruby Alexander’s Celia was impossible to ignore – her expressive performance, coupled with a light-up dress, made her a natural highlight. Working impeccably both in isolation and in unison, each and every performer contributed to the production’s whimsy, with both the Fairy Chorus and the Lords Chorus bringing vibrancy to each moment they inhabited.

While the performers excelled, much of the credit for the success of the production belongs to director Sarah Johnston. The creative vision, crafted by Sophie Essenhigh, has, under Johnston’s direction, been executed with meticulous precision. Every moment, from the subtle gestures conveying the poignant themes of both unrequited and requited love, to the delivery of comic moments, was choreographed with intention. A particularly striking moment featured a parallel vision – Iolanthe and the Lord Chancellor, mirrored by Phyllis and Strephon. The use of the curtain and spotlighting in this scene elevated the staging, adding a layer of professionalism and creativity. With creativity in mind, this was also reflected in the set design (Sarah Johnston). The whimsical inclusion of doors and windows within the mushrooms added a magical touch, further enriching the piece with a vibrant and convincing air.

Every moment, from the subtle gestures conveying the poignant themes of both unrequited and requited love, to the delivery of comic moments, was choreographed with intention

The orchestra lies at the heart of any opera; without them, the entire production would crumble. In this case, they were phenomenal. Under Michael Kohn’s musical direction, the orchestra delivered a flawless performance, bringing the operetta’s material to life with precision and flair. The strings (lead by Alison Roberts) shone during ‘Tripping Hither, Tripping Thither’, perfectly complementing the Fairy Chorus’ graceful movements. The brass section (Leo Vernaglioneand Matthew Prior) commanded attention in Act II’s Finale, adding a triumphant flourish to the opera’s conclusion. However, my personal highlight was the woodwinds, weaving effortlessly through the intricate passages of Love Unrequited— my favourite number from Gilbert and Sullivan’s score. The entire orchestra captured the effervescent comedy and poignant moments of the piece, with each note enhancing the production’s wit and magic.

Durham Opera Ensemble’s Iolanthe is a masterful blend of creativity and talent. From the impeccable direction, to the vibrant set design, each element worked harmoniously to bring Gilbert and Sullivan’s operetta to life. Whether you’re a seasoned opera-enjoyer, or totally new to the scene, this production is one to be enjoyed by all.

Durham Opera Ensemble’s Iolanthe is playing at the Assembly Rooms Theatre until March 1st, 2025. 

Image credit: Durham Opera Ensemble