Review: Foxcatcher

By Jared Isaacs

Image: Sony Pictures Classics
Image: Sony Pictures Classics

Here’s a sentence I never thought I’d write: Steve Carrell’s performance was fantastic. Here’s a second sentence I never thought I’d write: Channing Tatum was also great.

This based-on-a-true-story drama follows Mark Schultz (Channing Tatum) and his wrestling career, which changes when he is invited by Du Pont, (Steve Carrell as the ornithologist, philatelist, philanthropist and wrestling fan) to train at his new Foxcatcher facility. The story is less driven by the events of the plot but by the interesting cast of characters and their personalities. Specifically we are focused on the bizarre relationship between our protagonist and his benefactor, played perfectly by a creepy Carrell, and the strain it puts on his relationship with his brother. Mark Ruffalo plays Steve Schultz, the older brother who overshadows Tatum’s Mark, and gives a solid performance (though I’m not sure that Ruffalo can give a bad performance). By the start of the film both Schultz brothers are Olympic gold medallists, but Steve, as the more personable older brother and Mark’s trainer, has been given more of the spotlight. This makes Mark eager to take Du Pont’s offer to train at his facility.

With two fantastic supporting performances Tatum has his work cut out for him, but for once I think he works as a screen presence. Bennett Miller is known for getting career-best performances from his actors and I think he gets that from both Tatum and Carrell, the latter especially, and there is no doubt that Carrell will be nominated for awards for his performance. Like the rest of the performances, I never felt like I was watching Channing Tatum, for he really sold the image of the skilled but downtrodden wrestler. Relying mostly on physicality, Tatum’s portrayal of the awkward Schultz fits the subject matter perfectly. Throughout the film is a strong emphasis on this physicality: the Schultz brother’s relationship is mostly physical, their opening scene together says much with only a handful of words; whilst Du Pont is very wordy, both in his relationships with the brothers but also with his overbearing mother (a nice little turn from Vanessa Redgrave).

On the whole, the film is very quiet, which lends it a very foreboding tone whilst making the loud moments very shocking and impacting.  There is very sparse use of music and dialogue, making what music and dialogue there is very meaningful.

To some extent this is a sports movie – the wrestling is key to both the characters and the plot; but as per Miller’s previous film Moneyball this is really about the personalities, what sports represent, what it really means to be American, what it means to be a patriot. It also reveals different sides to the sporting world, such as showing how much egos are at play when it comes to sport. It is the very fact that Mark wants the limelight that drives him to Du Pont. Also key is the money, which is also a side rarely seen in sport-drama; the fact that athletes need to also need to provide for their families and make money as well as win medals.

Compelling from start to finish, this compelling drama uses sport to facilitate a twisted reflection on America. Tense, well written and packed with great performances and character relationships; Foxcatcher is gripping from start to finish and definitely one to watch this awards season.