Review: Every Brilliant Thing (@sohoplace)

By Ella Brannen

Rating: 5 out of 5.

Content warning: this article mentions suicide, depression, death, and other themes which some readers may find upsetting.

@sohoplace in London’s West End is currently reimagining Duncan Macmillan and Jonny Donahoe’s play, Every Brilliant Thing, which first premiered at the Edinburgh Fringe in 2014. The one-man play has since been performed over 400 times and in 63 countries – but it had never, until now, been performed in the West End. Blurring the bounds of stand-up comedy, improvisation, and audience participation, Every Brilliant Thing is spearheaded by a star-studded, rotating cast of Lenny Henry, Jonny Donahue, Ambit Mod, Sue Perkins, and Minnie Driver. I had the joy of witnessing ex-Bake-Off presenter, Sue Perkins, take on the exposing, spontaneous demands of this production. Much of the beauty of this adaptation is that no two performances are ever the same, given the rolling cast and interactive nature of the material.

The list serves as a hopeful reminder to dwell on the wonders of the human condition

Every Brilliant Thing is centred around the narrator – a nameless, genderless, universal figure – who traces their journey, from being a seven-year-old struggling with parental instability to adulthood, and grappling with the pressures of post-university life. The protagonist creates an ever-growing list of things that are brilliant in the world to give hope to their suicidal mother. As the protagonist reminisces on their mother’s life, as well as their own, the play is constantly anchored to the significance of this ‘list’. The two main requisites of the narrator’s list are, firstly, no repetition and, secondly, there must be an arbitrary limit on the number of materialistic items. This list, aptly titled ‘Every Brilliant Thing’, includes ‘waking up next to someone you love’ and ‘the subsequent state of calm you feel after realising that, although you have found yourself in a regrettable situation, there is nothing you can do about it.’ Some items on the list are certainly a little cliché or overly simplistic (for example ‘No. 2: Ice cream’) but nevertheless, the list serves as a hopeful reminder to dwell on the wonders of the human condition – especially given the fact that most of the list is steeped in brilliant feelings as opposed to materialistic things and therefore they are all the more accessible and fulfilling. While it could be said that the list is overly simplistic there is, however, a child-like joy to the fact that unassuming everyday things can be brilliant and create a life worth living for. 

But here is where the magic of the play lies: the audience is part of the story. By which I mean, before the play ‘begins’ (it had no definite start because Perkins was already on the stage, informally chatting to the audience and dancing jitterily before her scripted dialogue), willing members of the audience are given their ‘roles’. These audience members play characters that involve scripted and/or improvised lines. This has an interesting effect because every performance of the show will vary, and so the material remains fresh and dynamic – especially when Perkins’s stand-up comedy background surfaces and her quick wit always secures strong laughs. These improvised audience interactions with Perkins reflect the serendipity of life itself – accidental and spontaneous – these unfiltered, everyday interactions with other fellow human beings simultaneously surprise and unite us because they draw on the human psyche’s ingrained desire to socially bond and depend on others.

it is a story that is punctured with joy and hopeful revelations (and even a disco ball) which, held in tandem, leaves the audience feeling uplifted and that is a very brilliant thing

It is apparent that we, as the audience, are deliberately included in the narrator’s experience – with the fourth wall dismantled and the house lights remaining on during the play – the narrator’s reliving of their past is intimately cathartic and ultimately renders the story optimistic. The inspiration for the narrator’s list arises out of heavy themes of depression, but it is a story that is punctuated with joy and hopeful revelations (and even a disco ball) which, held in tandem, leaves the audience feeling uplifted, and that is a very brilliant thing.

The play raises the question of how suicide is presented in literature and throughout the media. The example given in the play is how (according to one study), after Marilyn Monroe’s death, the suicide rate in the United States increased by 12 percent compared with the same months in the previous year. This theory of ‘suicide contagion’ can be present in literature too, with Every Brilliant Thing pointing towards the ‘The Werther Effect’ – which was a term coined by David Phillips in the 1970s made in reference to the 18th century novel by Goethe called The Sorrows of Young Werther in which the hero of the novel tragically commits suicide after a failed love affair. Every Brilliant Thing only surfaces these complex ideas, but it does provoke questions around the potential moral complications of covering suicide in literary works and the danger of the media’s fascination with celebrity suicides. 

The emotional weight of the play is effectively counterbalanced with laughter and music, from the audience collectively dancing to Mayfield’s ‘Move on Up’, to the play pensively ending with the lyrics of O-o-o-h Child by the Five Stairsteps. Perkins is deliberate and thoughtful, unafraid of silence and sensitive to emotion; her performance is careful and poignant. Perkins opens up to the audience, willing to be vulnerable, especially when her billowy singing voice and tentative piano playing render her portrayal as humanly raw.

Overall, Every Brilliant Thing invites the audience in-the-round to be part of the narrator’s journey which speaks to the shared lived experience of humanity – communal and immersive – the audience and actor on stage become united as one. 

Every Brilliant Thing is running at @sohoplace until November 8th, 2025. Get your tickets here!

Image credit – Danny Kaan.