Review: Dial M For Mayhem!

By: Alexandra Roy

★★★★★

Founded in 1988, Middle Ground Theatre are a prolific production company, so hearing of their new comedy drama Dial M For Mayhem! filled me with excitement. I was intrigued by the premise – a take on Dial M For Murder, laced with the chaos of theatrical mishap. It promised to be a lively celebration of the genre, something with the potential to be both sharp and affectionate. While the production delivers on both energy, and a love of its source material, the reliance on predictable gags and the swept over emotional touch stagnates its potential.

The concept is one that should work: the play is self-referential, following a touring company as they rehearse Dial M For Murder. As the title suggests, “mayhem” ensues in a manner reminiscent of The Play That Goes Wrong, with numerous obstacles—ranging from an electricity meter to petty arguments and an escaped pet rat—hindering the smooth running of the production. Act One follows the rehearsal process on the day of the performance, particularly focusing on perfecting the infamous ‘murder’ scene. Act Two jumps ahead to the evening of the performance, offering the audience a backstage view of the unfolding chaos. Beneath the humour, the play attempts to weave in touching themes of friendship and budding relationships, forming a promising premise.

… the cast demonstrates an impressive command of physical comedy, with tightly choreographed sequences adding flair to the production’s more chaotic moments

At its best, this is a self-aware play imbued with fun. There’s an undeniable pleasure in watching actors commit fully to heightened performances, knowingly leaning into the genre’s clichés while maintaining professional precision. However, it is these very clichés that hold the production back. The gags – fart jokes and melodramatic reactions to superficial injuries to name a couple – though amusing at first, quickly become repetitive. Further, they seemed to overshadow the attempted balance between humour and heart. Where moments of poignant emotional connection were introduced, they were quickly neglected in favour of such gags. Thus, what initially feels like a loving tribute to the genre soon devolves into an overuse of familiar tropes. While older audience members seemed to revel in its nostalgic appeal, my own tonal preferences led me to resent its predictable beats at the expense of the emotional heart of the show.

Under the clever direction of Michael Lunney, the cast demonstrates an impressive command of physical comedy, with tightly choreographed sequences adding flair to the production’s more chaotic moments. Each performer stood out in their own right, seamlessly multi-roling. A particular highlight was Estrid Barton’s portrayal of both Jean Murray and Ellen Harrison—each role hilarious in isolation, made more impressive upon realising it was the same actor behind both characters. Theo Woolford also shone as Andy, bringing an authenticity that made his performance feel effortless. His portrayal of the loveable Welshman was natural and understated, a refreshing contrast to the otherwise exaggerated nature of the production. Another standout was Isabella Inchbald’s Sam Middleton, who injected a sense of heart amidst the frenzy. As a strong female lead, she projected vulnerability and self-awareness without compromising the power of her assured character. Her performance was phenomenal. The entire cast executed the vision with precision, humour, and heart, providing faultlessly executed performances.

The set (Michael Lunney, Mat Larkin) impressed me. With visible lighting rigs, realistic doors, a functioning curtain rail, and even a teapot filled with real liquid, the production successfully created an authentic rehearsal and performance space. The screen backdrop helped distinguish day from night, while off-stage water effects convincingly simulated rain. Act Two’s set reversal—flipping perspectives so the audience viewed the play from backstage—was a particularly clever touch, subtly communicating the shift in location and time without the need for exposition. Every detail was meticulously considered, from a repositioned heater to props that maintained continuity.

Ultimately, Dial M for Mayhem! is an enjoyable, if somewhat underwhelming, theatrical experience

The show blurred the lines between set and prop, often to comedic effect. Some props were ingeniously utilised for humour—an AA mug in Act Two was a personal favourite. However, other gags felt too on-the-nose, leading to stagnation. The rat subplot, for instance, was heavily implied yet lacked an actual rat prop to drive the joke home, making it feel ineffective and repetitive. Similarly, the overuse of tripping and prop-based humour—particularly the AA man’s antics—felt superfluous and, at times, confusing, often failing to land successfully with the audience. With that said, the utilisation of props – as with the set – generated an authenticity which bolstered the performance quality further.

Ultimately, Dial M for Mayhem! is an enjoyable, if somewhat underwhelming, theatrical experience. It thrives when it embraces its stylish, knowing approach but stumbles when it overindulges in its own cleverness. While it offers moments of undeniable charm and sharp wit, the production doesn’t always strike the balance between homage and overstatement. Fans of the genre will likely find much to enjoy, but for those less enamoured, the mayhem may wear thin. Dial M For Mayhem! is playing at the Darlington Hippodrome until Saturday 22nd February, 2025. Get your tickets here!

Image Credit: Darlington Hippodrome