Review: Cruel Intentions – The ’90s Musical

By Alex Roy

★★★★★

I am a firm believer that jukebox musicals get a bad reputation, and unfairly so. When executed well, they can be a thrilling celebration of nostalgia, storytelling, and theatrical spectacle. Cruel Intentions is a perfect example of this – an unapologetically bold, irresistibly fun production that leans into its own silliness with style. Packed with iconic ‘90s hits, sharp humour and a wildly twisted plot, this show delivers 115 minutes of pure entertainment.

Based on the cult-classic film, Cruel Intentions follows deviant step-siblings Sebastian Valmont (Will Callan) and Kathryn Merteuil (Nic Myers) as they revel in their hedonistic lifestyle. With money than sense, they strike a depraved wager: if Sebastian can seduce and sleep with Annette Hargrove (Abbie Budden) – the principal’s virgin daughter – he will finally be allowed to bed his own step-sister, with whom he is infatuated. If he fails however, Kathryn gets his beloved car. Meanwhile, caught in their web of deception is the innocent Cecile Caldwell (Lucy Carter), who becomes collateral damage in their cruel games. Lust, deceit, power and dark comedy make this musical an outrageously sexy, absurd and highly entertaining ride.

The premise itself is completely unhinged – outrageous, camp, and delightfully messy. However, under the sharp directorial vision of Jonathan O’Boyle, that which could have descended into farcical chaos instead became a meticulously crafted piece of theatre. Nowhere was this clearer than in the Act One finale, Only Happy When It Rains. As the consequences of Kathryn’s schemes exploded into mayhem, Myers stood motionless, simply watching the chaos erupt around her. It was in this moment that her role as the puppet master became chillingly clear, orchestrating her evil vision with an eerie precision.

Loud, proud, and incredibly silly

The cast carried O’Boyle’s bold vision with utter ease. The standout of the evening was undoubtedly Myers’ Kathryn – she commanded each scene with a perfect mix of seduction, cruelty and effortless dominance. Her subtle mannerisms, deliberately slow movement and powerful vocals made for a masterclass in controlled villainy, particularly conveyed in her Act Two downfall. Carter’s Cecile was another highlight. Having previously seen her in Babies: The Musical last summer, it was a joy to watch her transition into a more mature (yet still wonderfully naïve) role. Callan as Sebastian struck a beautiful balance between entitled arrogance and fragile insecurity. His tentative balance here provided a great touch of emotional realism amidst the otherwise absurd nature of this production. Abbie Budden’s iteration of Annette was a delight. Watching her transformation from innocent idealist to empowered woman was beautiful, and her voice was showcased wonderfully through her songs. Finally, a special mention must go to Luke Conner Hall, whose characterisation of Blaine Tuttle carried the camp, comedic nature of the show. From aggressive nail filing, to hilariously flamboyant movements, his line delivery and execution of the choreography (Gary Lloyd) was awe-inspiring.

The intimacy coordination (Rebecca Reaney) deserves recognition for its subtlety and effectiveness. As the show deals with some intense themes of sex, love, power and manipulation, it was crucial that these moments were handled with both boldness and care. The result of Reaney’s coordination was a production that embraced sensuality while avoiding unnecessary over-sexualisation. Clever choreography (Lloyd) and deliberate physicality ensured that intimacy remained suggestive rather than explicit, with lighting and ensemble numbers enhancing the tension and emotional weight of such encounters throughout.

Speaking of lighting, it was utilised brilliantly throughout (Nick Richings). The vibrant colour shifts that distinguished spoken scenes from dream-like song sequences added to the show’s playful self-awareness. A standout moment saw Connor Hall burst into Wannabe as the stage was suddenly bathed in pink – a perfectly timed, camp, comedic touch. Additionally, strategic lighting was used to ‘blind’ the audience at key moments, disguising set changes, plot twists, and implied moments of intimacy. It was an inventive technique, executed flawlessly.

The set and costume design also contributed to the show’s heightened reality. A minimalistic yet effective setup featured a balcony – used effectively for character introduction and establishing a degree of omnipresence – along with chaise longues, chandeliers, beanbags and LED panels which shifted colour to indicate different locations. The costumes were equally well thought out, with sunglasses serving as a particularly clever symbol of power. Kathryn and Sebastian wore them throughout the show, only for Annette to don them in the final moments – visually marking the shift in dominance.

The writing itself is a masterclass in jukebox musical execution. The script is sharp, packed with one-liners, innuendos and intertextual reference which make for a hilariously audacious theatrical experience. The songs are woven in with surprising finesse, embracing the genre’s inherent absurdity with open arms. It is loud, proud, and incredibly silly.

Cruel Intentions is riotous, provocative and utterly ridiculous in the best way possible. It doesn’t take itself too seriously, and that is precisely what makes it such a triumph. Whether you’re a longtime fan of the film, or encountering the story for the first time, this show is electrifying from start to finish.

Cruel Intentions is playing at the York Grand Opera House until Saturday 22nd February, 2025. Get your tickets here.

Image credit: Pamela Raith