Review: Consent on Campus: A Manifesto

By April Howard

Donna Freitas’ investigation into the pitfalls of consent education and the issue of sexual violence on college campuses in the US is an incredibly well-researched one, drawing on a broad range of credible sources. She writes from a place of experience and knowledge and is a reliable authority on the issues discussed.

an approach that I find refreshing

Freitas begins with an address to university presidents, beginning the chain of her argument which she follows throughout the book, attacking institutions of higher education as failing in their duty of care. She denounces their attempts to cover themselves, at the expense of investing real time and energy into positive action, to prevent and punish sexual assaults. She advocates for an academic programme which does not side-line education about consent as irrelevant and the duty of external sources. It’s an approach that I find refreshing, considering the previous trope of blaming students for drinking, and the promotion of consent education being the solely the duty of parents and PSHE teachers.

She presents her arguments in a fair, systematic fashion. She does not diminish the issue of male victims but points out that, statistically speaking, rape is an issue disproportionately affecting women. She quotes figures that women have a one in five chance of being raped while men have a chance of one in 71. By no means does that mean those one in 71 men are less important than the one in five women, but she refuses to fall into the trap cultivated by “Men’s Rights Activists” of making rape about male victimisation. She demands we look at gender norms in regards to these figures; why women are raped more and also why male victims largely refuse to report. Both of these issues can be attributed to patriarchal values.

Freitas blends the personal and impersonal, the red-hot emotion of sexual violence and the cold rationality of academia.

She discusses Title IX, mostly its shortcomings, she tears it apart but goes on to say, “imperfect and insufficient” as it is, it is desperately needed. Never staying static in her view, she is always lively in her contemplation of the pros and cons of the process.

It is of great advantage to her writing that she combines an academic mode of argument with real- life examples and anecdotes. Freitas blends the personal and impersonal, the red-hot emotion of sexual violence and the cold rationality of academia. She retains reason yet does not diminish the emotional implications of rape culture on the lives of humans. Rape is a human issue, she serves it well by treating it as such.

In this way, she pays homage to the victim, always placing them first, roaring in the face of victim blaming and tearing its foundations down to the ground. She impresses on the reader how it must feel to be a victim but see before you an unscalable wall which blocks you from justice. A notion even more relevant in our time, absorbed in the culture of ‘#MeToo’.

the simple mantra “no means no” often grossly misreads common sexual practices.

Donna Freitas calls for a nuanced approach to discussions of consent, avoiding the blinkered outlook which does not work within the confines of norms of hook- up culture. She cries for us to tear down the current system and build a new one eventually but, for now, to be aware of the society in which we are working. That the simple mantra “no means no” often grossly misreads common sexual practices.

One shortcoming I found of this book is that Freitas does tend to reiterate a point numerous times, which to me made the text minimally less engaging. However, some readers may find this helps solidify the argument, reflecting the need for clarification in regard to the sensitive issues discussed.

thoughtful, taboo-busting argument

I would recommend this book to all. It is, of course, particularly relevant to the Durham University community and to anyone interested in a thoughtful, taboo-busting argument. Nonetheless, it deserves to be read by all, or at least discussed; consent is not just an issue for young feminists but for everyone. Freitas explores all relevant issues practically and considerately. For the individual who seeks to be better engaged with the world, with a culture that permeates all of our lives, this philosophical and reasoned manifesto is a must-read.

Consent on Campus: A Manifesto will be released 10th January 2019.

Photograph: Wikimedia Commons