Review: Animal Farm (Collingwood Woodplayers)

By Alex Roy

Rating: 5 out of 5.

All student theatre is equal, but some is more equal than others, and every so often a production comes along that reminds us of its magic. Robyn Bradbury’s adaptation of George Orwell’s Animal Farm is unmistakably one of these rarities; from concept to execution, it carries the rare duality of being both unmistakably student-led and yet fully comparable to professional work.

For the uninitiated, Animal Farm charts the rise and fall of an animalistic revolution. When the animals of Manor Farm overthrow their negligent owner, Mr Jones, they establish a new society founded on egalitarian ideals. Yet, the utopia they envision gradually dissolves. The pigs, led by the increasingly authoritarian Napoleon, manipulate language, law, and memory until the revolution’s promises are unrecognisable. What begins as hope curdles into tyranny, and Orwell’s political allegory remains as cutting today as it was in 1945.

The sense of collective determination mirrored the production’s own theme of endurance

This particular performance began with an unexpected obstacle: fire alarms delayed the start by around an hour, turning off the sound box and plunging the team into logistical chaos. Yet what followed epitomised resilience and determination. The producers, cast, and creatives – most notably lighting operator Anj Karia and stage managers Moksh Bora and Aakash Jeph – worked tirelessly to start the show. Their refusal to give up not only salvaged the evening but somehow made it more powerful; the sense of collective determination mirrored the production’s own theme of endurance.

On this, lighting design by Zac Jackson became one of the production’s defining assets. Timely blackouts punctuated the action with sharp intention. Nowhere was this more effective than during the Act II ‘confessions’ sequence, where each blackout paired with disturbingly visceral screams (Nancy Beascanon’s was chilling), created a rhythm of dread. Subtler touches landed just as effectively, such as the creeping red overhead lighting during the final ‘toast’ to Animal Farm’s corruption, a visual echo of the play’s descent into moral decay.

The performances were nothing short of exceptional. Multi-roling is a demanding requirement of Animal Farm, yet each actor handled it with clarity and care. Lewis Naylor’s Benjamin was a highlight of the evening – dryly cynical, quietly wise, and later deeply affecting. Matthew Lo’s Mr Jones brought a welcome dose of tragicomic energy, stumbling and slumping with just the right balance of humour and pathos.

Nancy Beascanon’s Mollie was utterly delightful: whimsical and irresistibly charming, her 27 Ribbons song was a moment of sweetness amidst the farm’s chaos. Dan Katsande delivered a moving Old Major and an especially heartbreaking Boxer, played with a sincerity that made his Act II fate almost unbearable.

She stitched the entire political world of the play together with quiet authority and chilling charm

Mwambu Haimbe’s Napoleon was magnificent in his subtle menace, balancing stillness, smirks, and a slow-burn cruelty that made his transformation eerily believable. Yet the standout performance of the night came from Claudia Schreuder as Squealer. Her control of tone, her finely tuned physicality, and her razor-sharp delivery made her magnetic. She stitched the entire political world of the play together with quiet authority and chilling charm.

The production’s use of projection set it apart from anything I’ve seen in college theatre previously. With the Mark Hillary cloaked in black curtains and configured in traverse, Jackson’s lighting design in this respect transformed the space. Projected text – the Seven Commandments – glowed, mimicking scripture, while a propaganda-style video of Napoleon added a dimension of satire that was bold, thoughtful, and brilliantly executed (even with the curtain-induced face-warping evoking unfortunate laughter from the audience).

But above all, it was Robyn Bradbury’s direction that elevated the show to professional heights. Her decision to frame the play through an explicit reading of Orwell’s text was ingenious, granting narrative clarity and giving every cast member a moment to shine. Early on, the choice to have the line “Man is the enemy” delivered directly to the audience cemented the production’s intent: this Animal Farm implicates us; it demands reflection.

Bradbury’s choice to replace traditional wings with entrances and exits through the curtains created a sense of immersion, making the farm feel inescapable. The traverse staging was used to exceptional effect, particularly in a confrontation scene where opposing lines of animals mirrored the audience’s seating, forcing us into the emotional geometry of the moment.

Collingwood Woodplayers Theatre Company have successfully pushed the limits of college theatre. Politically sharp, emotionally resonant, and executed with artistic precision, this Animal Farm is a triumph in every sense, and is an absolute must-see in Durham this week.

Animal Farm plays at the Mark Hillary Arts Centre until Saturday 29 November, 2025. Tickets available here.

Image Credit: Lee Yi Yang