Review: ‘A Real Pain’
By Roksana Stanislawska
A Real Pain (2024) is a comedy film about two Jewish-American cousins visiting Poland for the first time after the passing of their grandmother Dory, a Holocaust survivor. Despite being categorised as a comedy, the film evoked strong emotions in me for several reasons. One of the most striking aspects was the cinematography of Poland. Eisenberg captures the beauty of everyday Polish life impressively well; despite the fact he had only visited Poland a handful of times. The montages of ordinary, often overlooked locations—street corners, staircases, and back alleys of cafés—transported me back to my home country. Whilst admiring the films portrayal of Poland, I realised that perhaps I had been overlooking and taking for granted the beauty of the place where I grew up. These still shots perfectly highlighted the charm of seemingly unremarkable places, evoking a deep sense of nostalgia for me. Sitting in the cinema, immersed in the stunning summer scenery, I found myself missing home.
Circling back to the plot, at the heart of A Real Pain is the compelling and often tumultuous relationship between the two cousins, Benji and David. Despite the comedic undertones of the film, what truly captivates the audience is the charged dynamic between the cousins, skilfully portrayed by Kieran Culkin and Jesse Eisenberg. Their chemistry is unique, marked by moments of deep affection, but also by simmering anger, resentment, and jealousy. This tension makes perfect sense given their stark contrasts—Benji is an extroverted, outgoing character who effortlessly connects with others, while David is a more introverted, socially awkward figure. I felt that Benji and David acted like a mirror of insecurities for each other; when they look at their cousin, they see all the qualities that they themselves lack. When watching these characters interact, I couldn’t help but hear the lyrics from ‘Girl, So Confusing’ by Charli XCX in my head. The cousins’ bond feels authentic, and despite their differences, it’s clear they both harbour a deep love for one another.
The montages of ordinary, often overlooked locations—street corners, staircases, and back alleys of cafés—transported me back to my home country
That being said, Benji is definitely the film’s standout character. Culkin’s acting methods are eccentric, since he is known for avoiding rehearsals and rarely learning his lines. His distinctive acting style and personality make it hard to imagine anyone else bringing Benji to life with such depth. Benji initially seems like the kind of character who would be easily dismissed as loud and annoying—something hinted at by the film’s opening title scene, where he sits in an airport with the title A Real Pain displayed next to him. But as we get to know him, we see a more complex side. Benji is a gregarious, outgoing individual who has an unmatched ability to leave a meaningful impact on those around him, often without even realising it. His charm and warmth contrast sharply with David’s quiet, reserved nature, but what really makes Benji stand out is the quiet sadness beneath his exterior. As we learn about his struggles with mental health and the burdens of his past, the film transforms from a comedy into something much deeper. Culkin’s Golden Globe-winning performance allows us to slowly uncover Benji’s vulnerabilities, making him an incredibly compelling character whose outward happiness masks a deeper, unspoken pain.
As the film unfolds further, we begin to understand the real significance of the title A Real Pain—it becomes a reflection not just on the everyday, personal struggles of the characters, but also a deeper, generational trauma. While A Real Pain takes us on a comedic journey through Poland, it also explores much heavier themes related to history, genocide, and the legacy of the Holocaust. Eisenberg mocks the idea of ‘Holocaust tourism’, providing a critical look at how modern-day visits to concentration camps can sometimes feel like a detached, almost commercialised experience. I think I speak for most Poles when I say this aspect of tourism in our country can be inconsiderate and upsetting. Thankfully, the film’s portrayal of a silent tour of a concentration camp serves as a respectful, reflective moment, allowing the audience to pause and deeply consider the painful history of Poland.
Eisenberg mocks the idea of ‘Holocaust tourism’, providing a critical look at how modern-day visits to concentration camps can sometimes feel like a detached, almost commercialised experience
This sombre exploration is also mirrored in the personal struggles of Benji, whose character reflects the complicated emotions of the post-war generation experience when dealing with survivors’ guilt. Following the tour, we witness his character cycling through feelings of anger, remorse, and hopelessness. In these moments, I felt a deep connection to Benji’s character, as I’m sure many others did. Learning about the violent, sorrowful history of your family is an important yet unavoidable experience, but it remains difficult nonetheless. Through these emotional scenes, we can begin to empathise with the weight carried by those who follow on from their ancestors. This pain is further highlighted when we consider the close relationship Benji had with his beloved Grandma Dory. Although the film poignantly reminds us of the pain experienced by previous generations in Poland, it urged me to channel this anger and guilt into activism. This message is becoming increasingly relevant as far-right, anti-immigrant rhetoric rises once more. In this way, A Real Pain serves as a powerful warning, reminding us of history’s tragic lessons and the need to prevent such horrors from repeating themselves in the future.
Image credit: Searchlight Pictures

