Review: 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee

By Oliver Ebeling-Jones

For most of us just the idea of a spelling bee is enough to make one’s blood run cold and to increase anxiety levels stratospherically. The prospect of being asked in public to spell the most complicated and tedious words of our language is not the stuff that musicals are made of but rather the stuff which fuels our nightmares.

I confess with this image in my mind, I went last night to see the opening night of a new production of the 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee produced by the Tone Death Theatre Company (TDTC) performed at the Sir Thomas Allen Assembly Rooms Theatre. Ostensibly a musical, this production also had a clear comedic voice and sensibility and all members of the cast worked well combining the big musical numbers and cleverly constructed and executed comedic scenes. Undoubtedly, this combination of music and comedy did make this production feel very lively, light and really did manage to capture the whimsical spirit to be found at the heart of Rachel Sheinkin’s musical.

The conceit of this very American musical is that we are watching a high school spelling bee with admittedly shallow characters straight out of any American high school movie or television series. There is the shy and socially awkward nerd, the unsatisfied over-achiever and a rather brash character who declares during the first half “my unfortunate protuberance seems to have its own exuberance”, subtlety was obviously not at the front of Sheinkin’s mind. To the credit of the cast all parts were executed with great energy and enthusiasm within the long tradition of the American musical. The most noteworthy performances were given by Lucie Fletcher (Hatfield) whose performance as Rona (one of the adjudicators at the Bee) really helped this production keep on track in the whimsical and fast paced world of the Musical. Credit should also go to Jonas Stringer (University) whose performance as Barfee served to capture the coming of age spirit of this musical.

… impressive and energetic acting  accompanied by an equally energetic band demonstrated the depth of musical theatre talent we currently have here in Durham.

From cast to band, perhaps one of the most enjoyable components of this production was the fact that all of the music was performed live. This added to the energy of the cast and made one appreciate the musical numbers and,in all, the production felt more of a musical event than if a banal backing track had been used. On this point, this combination of impressive and energetic acting  accompanied by an equally energetic band demonstrated the depth of musical theatre talent we currently have here in Durham.

Perhaps the bravest creative choice made by this production is the inclusion of audience participation. This was part of the original production on Broadway of course but it is still a significant choice considering this production has such a small and close knit cast, it would seem quite the risk to interrupt such a small group of actors. One would fear that audience participation could negatively interfere with the overall style and tone of the cast. Personally, I have always been a stern opponent of audience participation for the reasons I have just listed and the fact that it has struck me as a rather gimmicky and route one dramatic choice. When Sir Laurence Olivier was performing Hamlet at the height of his acting powers, Sir Laurence didn’t cast his gaze down to the first row and asked an audience member if they fancied having a go at to be or not to be. Yet despite my own biases against audience participation in the theatre, to the credit to the cast and production team those lucky or unlucky enough to (depending on your perspective) be hurled up onto the stage did fit well into the cast and plot and did not disrupt the energy at all of this production. 

In all, this production, directed by Archie Collins (Van Mildert), was a humorous and lively combination of music and comedy and well worth a night out at the theatre for during this rather tense period in the life of an undergraduate. 

Image credit: Tone Death Theatre Company