Reunited at last! But do we still care?
The music of both the Red Hot Chilli Peppers and Blink-182 doubtlessly constituted the soundtrack to many of our halcyon early teen years, with their peaks of stardom back in the early noughties. This autumn, both bands have reformed and are bringing out brand new material for the first time in years. The question is, is their new music still interesting, relevant, or even necessary today?
The Chillis are no strangers to a fluctuating band line-up, from the tragic death of first guitarist Hillel Slovak in 1988, to their experimental Dave Navarro stage between 1993-98. The band had seemed rooted, however, with Anthony Kiedis, Flea, Chad Smith, and John Frusciante, and the group released Mother’s Milk (1989), Blood Sex Sugar Magik (1991), Californiacation (1999), By The Way (2002), and Stadium Arcadium (2006) together. Stadium Arcadium garnered generally positive reviews, and became the band’s first ever number one album in the US.
However, it was also criticised for being over-produced and self-indulgent, with the band’s diverse influences being spun out to their extremes over the double LP. Their following world tour, which included a forgettable headline set at Reading and Leeds in 2007, saw a mixed reaction from fans and, in early 2009, the band declared they were going on an indefinite hiatus. Two years later, with former back-up guitarist Josh Klinghoffer replacing Frusciante, the Chilli Peppers are set to release their tenth studio album “I’m With You” later this August, five years since their last release.
The first hints of what the album will be like are not too promising. There’s nothing particularly wrong with first single “The Adventures of Rain Dance Maggie” – Kiedis’s unique funk-soul vocals, Flea’s mesmerising bass, and Chad Smith’s tight drumming are all there – but the blood-sex-sugar-magic just doesn’t seem to be coursing through the band’s veins any more without Frusciante. In short, this lead single would melt into B-side obscurity on any of the band’s last few release

The same disappointment can be found in Blink-182’s forthcoming release. Having fizzled into an indefinite hiatus in 2005 as members Tom DeLonge and Mark Hoppus had a much-publicized fall-out, the band reformed in the summer of 2009 for a series of highly praised “greatest hits” gigs throughout the US and Europe, before knuckling down in the studio. The resulting album,
“Neighborhoods”, tentatively penned for release on 27 September, seems doomed to disappoint one section of the band’s fans, no matter what they do.
The lose-lose situation for Hoppus, DeLonge, and drummer, Travis Barker relates to their age, with all of them on the wrong side of 35. No longer “seventeen without a purpose and direction”, stomachs would have turned if Blink’s new songs stuck to the “Enema of the State” or “Take Off Your Pants and Jacket” formula of songs about first dates and bestiality.
Conversely, if they struck out in a completely new direction, Blink-182 would risk alienating their ever patient hardcore of fans. The compromising sound, as heard in the recently released tracks “Up All Night” and “Hearts All Gone”, falls squarely in the middle. On the one hand, both tracks can be seen as logical progressions from the group’s last effort in 2003, which showed signs of a developing maturity. On the other hand, however, post-Blink-182 projects Angels and Airwaves (DeLonge and Barker) and +44 (Hoppus and Barker) both followed these developments, therefore neither of these songs seem to add anything new to the trio’s repertoire. The problem that both these returning megabands have is that the clock is against their ever reaching the heights of their respective musical peaks. While the release of new material, and the live shows that will inevitably follow, can’t be seen as a negative thing, neither of these releases will reach the staggering popularity and acclaim of previous albums.
RHCP have been chugging on since 1983, while Blink-182 formed at High School in 1992. Only time will tell whether the completed albums will reinforce the first impressions of these singles, but, to paraphrase a rock ‘n’ roll cliché, perhaps it would have been better for these bands to have burned out at their peak, than to fade away with lacklustre reunion releases.

