Returning the Nazi art trove
While searching an apartment in Munich, police stumbled upon a collection of nearly 1,500 paintings, drawings and illustrations from artists such as Picasso, Matisse and Chagall.
Experts say that the works were seized from their owners during Nazi rule in Germany as part of measures to stamp down on ‘degenerate’, non-Aryan, avant-garde culture. Such works had been displayed in the notorious ‘Entartete Kunst’ – the Degenerate Art exhibition staged by the Nazis in Munich in 1937. The intention of this exhibition was to allow German citizens to mock the ‘vulgar’ art on display, and it had been comfortably sealed in the past until earlier this month when a huge collection of these ‘degenerate’ works was discovered by German authorities.
Meite Hoffmann, the art historian researching and documenting this newfound collection, said: “When you stand before the works and see again these long-lost, missing works, that were believed destroyed, seeing them in quite good condition, it’s an extraordinarily good feeling.”
The apartment in which these works were kept was owned by Cornelius Gurlitt, son of the prominent Munich art dealer Hildebrand Gurlitt – the man charged with selling off the works from the Degenerate Art exhibition.
What’s bizarre about this story is how the Bavarian authorities have known about this secret haul for over two and a half years. The issue only surfaced through an unintended leak in the German magazine ‘Focus.’ Furthermore, Andrea Merkel’s spokesman, upon hearing about the story, said on Monday that she been “informed about the case for several months.” Investigators and authorities claimed they didn’t reveal the case until now because they had come across the art by chance during a tax evasion probe, which requires secrecy.
The haul is one of the most significant discoveries of works seized by the Nazi regime. With such an important find, one must ask the question: was it right for the German authorities to keep it from the public for so long?
“You have to wonder what is behind the extreme reluctance to provide information,” says Anne Webber, of the London-based Commission for Looted Art in Europe. “We have reminded the Bavarian authorities of the need for transparency and requested a full list of the works. So far we have had no response.”
The Bavarian authorities have defended their actions. Experts know that the works of art are of great artistic value, yet the task of returning them to their rightful owners could take many years and poses huge legal and moral problems.
For this reason, Chief Prosecutor Nemetz claimed the publication of the Focus article was “counter-productive.” Not only will it delay the time taken to get the works documented, but it will also make the paintings less safe. “We don’t want to hang on to these works. Nor were we planning to put them up in our offices,” he insisted.
Customs officials have argued that “Keeping things secret is the best way to keep them safe“. Instead of advertising this hugely valuable collection, it was hoped that people with a claim to ownership would actually contact the authorities directly.
A number of museums and descendants of gallerists have already responded to the call. One painting, ‘The Lion Tamer’ by Max Beckmann, was sold by Gurlitt in 2011 to an auction house in Cologne. The work had originally belonged to the Jewish art dealer and collector Alfred Flechtheim, whose heirs are now inquiring if further pieces are in the possession of the Bavarian authorities.
However, there is still anger among Jewish groups who are urging that the provenance of the paintings be researched as quickly as possible so that they can be returned to their original owners. For some families, missing art constitutes the last personal effects of relatives murdered during the Holocaust. No wonder, then, that such a discovery has aroused so much controversy.
“Had this discovery been made public at the time it was made, families looking for their lost art would have been able to potentially identify works within this collection,” Julius Berman, chairman of the Conference on Jewish Material Claims Against Germany, said.
In light of these issues, we must evaluate whether the German authorities have been in their right to be so shrewd about the discovery of such an important collection of art.
In my opinion, whilst such anger amongst Jewish groups is justified, it would be unwise to advertise the paintings to the public. This could jeopardize the safety of the works of art, as well as delaying the time taken to deal with the matter.
The authorities have told us that they have a reliable art historian, Meite Hoffmann, working on documenting and categorizing the collection. And they have been quite clear in telling the public that they should contact the authorities directly if they have a claim to a certain painting. There isn’t much else they can do without explicitly advertising the works of art to the general public.
This is the most sensible way of proceeding. However, it will not stop the press and public from questioning their motives. One therefore hopes that more and more descendants will start claiming ownership of the paintings that are rightfully theirs. This issue can be then resolved in a way that isn’t detrimental to a collection that is in all our best interests to protect.
Photograph 1: Joseph Goebbels visiting the Entartete Kunst exhibition in 1937. From Wikimedia Commons.
Photograph 2: Franz Marc’s 1911 ‘Horses in Landscape’ is one of the artworks that has been discovered. From Wikimedia Commons

