Return of the reperations debate: The King’s visit to the Caribbean

By Harry Armstrong

King Charles’ nine-day trip to the Caribbean for the Commonwealth Heads of Government Meeting has brought the reparations debate under renewed scrutiny.  In June of this year, the 15-member Caribbean Community (CARICOM) and the African Union agreed to a 19-point reparations plan, placing pressure on the UK government ahead of the meeting. The plan included formal apologies, debt relief and an international reparatory justice fund.

While Buckingham Palace has indicated that the King will not give a formal apology for slavery on this tour, the Prime Minister signalled in a social media video that his government is ‘open’ to doing so. This marks a changed tone from that of Sir Keir Starmer in 2024, when the ex-PM’s insistence that the reparations debate was not on the table clashed with Commonwealth leaders. This change is also visible in Mr Burnham’s recent opinion piece in The Guardian where he took a more consultative tone, writing that his government will engage in ‘structured dialogue’ on the slave trade. However, the UK Government remains consistent in its opposition to financial reparations for slavery, which Mr Burnham’s article affirmed.

 

Yet calls for reparations are not dwindling. Indeed, they are becoming more formal, organised and high-profile in recent years. This puts pressure on an already fragile Commonwealth community which faces geopolitical challenges from BRICS and particularly the attempts by China to forge closer ties to its members. As Mr Burnham noted, ignoring questions on slavery has ‘damaged the ability of the Commonwealth to function.’ 

Yet calls for reparations are not dwindling. Indeed, they are becoming more formal, organised and high-profile in recent years

It would mark a significant break with traditional UK foreign policy were the Government, or the King on its behalf, to apologise. While David Cameron did offer a formal apology for the events of Bloody Sunday, the Government has stopped short of apologising for actions taken during the colonial era including the 1919 Amritsar Massacre and the events of the Mau Mau uprising in the 1950’s. The standard approach is to offer regret rather than an apology. Tony Blair did so for the Irish Famine and the Amritsar Massacre was addressed by David Cameron and Theresa May. This allows the government to avoid taking responsibility, with its possible legal and diplomatic consequences, while still being seen as acknowledging the events that occurred.  

An apology also carries political risk. Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch has characterised an apology ‘as a lever to wedge the door open to ask for cash.’ This underlines the difficulty of offering the former without then being ‘bounced’ into the latter. Reparations carry even more risk in terms of domestic political backlash, with 44% of adults strongly opposed according to a YouGov survey in March 2026.  

Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch has characterised an apology ‘as a lever to wedge the door open to ask for cash’

This is where Mr Burnham’s plans for a ‘debt reset’ could be a diplomatic way of threading the needle. While currently unclear, this could mean some form of financial aid for those Commonwealth countries with crippling debt interest costs. Combined with plans for two new task forces focused on critical mineral assets and supply chains and on boosting trade and investment, this could signal a new approach to addressing the enduring issue of the slave trade.  

Buckingham Palace is keen to stress that King Charles’ role is symbolic and unifying, one that is strictly above political interference and comment. Therefore, he faces a difficult balancing act between maintaining the unity and relevance of the Commonwealth without creating political backlash at home.  

Ultimately, the success of the tour depends on whether Mr Burnham and King Charles can tread this fine line and what the backlash might be if they are seen as to go too far, or not far enough. Too little, and Commonwealth leaders may conclude that the UK is still unwilling to confront its past, deepening divisions and leaving the door open to rivals such as China to gain more influence. Too much, and the Government risks a damaging domestic reaction, with the monarchy possibly drawn into a political row it has long sought to avoid.  

The tour may not settle the reparations debate, but it will show whether the UK can acknowledge its history and bolster its international influence, without making significant financial concessions. 

Image: Arlington National Cemetary via Flickr