Response: Occupy protesters should keep up the good work
This article is a response to one by Hugh Westlake published in Palatinate on 22nd November 2011. The original article is available here: http://www.palatinate.org.uk/?p=17507
By Adam Robertson
In an article about the Occupy London protests in the most recent edition of Palatinate, Hugh Westlake criticised the protesters assumption to speak as the representative voice of the population, before going on to assume to speak on all of our behalves in proclaiming that we had rejected the protesters’ message. Well, in the same spirit, I would like to speak on behalf of the protesters and inform Mr. Westlake of what they want: to challenge the boorish views of people like him.
Since the end of the Cold War, capitalism has been ‘triumphant’. That is in the sense of becoming the unquestioned dominant ideology of the world. There appear to be no alternatives: any criticism of the status quo has been labelled anti-capitalist. Therefore, by extension, the protest must somehow be emphatically pro-communist, as this is apparently the only alternative system that commentators can call to mind. But to suggest that taking umbrage at excessive boardroom pay, at a time of welfare cuts and wage freezes, is an endorsement of a communist police state is at best intellectually lazy and at worst extremely disingenuous.
It is this inability to think beyond this dichotomy of capitalism and communism which led to our inability to remedy the systemic problems which lay behind the crisis of 2008. It was a failure which created a depression that is now worse than that of the early 1930s. Rather than applying the label of anti-capitalist to the Occupy movement, instead we should apply the label ‘anti-status quo’.
The movement is functioning as a space in which discussions can be held as to how best to change the structures which govern our lives, which recent events have shown to be plainly unfit for purpose. Yes this discussion will include communists, but this does not mean that the answer reached by the movement will be ‘Communism’. It is aiming to include every aspect of society in the discussion, especially those involved in the financial sector, hence the camp’s originally intended location in front of the London Stock Exchange, and its current location in front of an M&S food store which, I can only assume, provides lunch to the entire workforce of the City given the length of its queues.
This attempt to discuss how to bring about a fairer system is seen as a threat to those doing nicely out of the current system (who we now have a handy term for, thanks to the Occupy movement: the 1%). The propaganda machines of the right are mobilised and the protesters are labelled ‘anti-capitalists’ who are against everything good about modern Britain. But this is a battle they cannot win.
Although, judging by Mr. Westlake’s article, they have succeeded in turning swathes of public opinion against the protesters themselves, largely discrediting the discussions going on outside St. Paul’s cathedral. In fixing the Occupy movement on the far left of most people’s imagination, the messages and actions from the movement are considered by people to be extreme. But in resuscitating the spectre of the hard-left previously extreme beliefs have become accepted as mainstream.
In this context, figures as politically disparate as Ed Miliband and Nigel Farage have found themselves agreeing that there is a need to reform aspects of the capitalist system that are socially unjust or economically unviable. The Occupy protest is having a real and direct effect on the discourse around the reform of the current capitalist system, with Angela Merkel recently proposing a Europe-wide Robin Hood Tax, a proposition only supported by activist groups as recently as this summer. Who could have envisaged groups of the world’s wealthiest citizens petitioning governments to tax them more in the years of Blair, Brown, and the end of boom and bust?
So no, the Occupy protesters have not made their point, and nor should they move on. They have broken the silence around reform that was maintained by interested parties after the crash of 2008, and are changing the landscape of debate about the world that we want to live in at a time when politicians have seemed increasingly unlikely to do so. I can only hope that they stay there until we live in a society with an economic system that works for the 99%, and not for the greedy few.

