Research Assessment Exercise a success, despite confusion
ONLY COMING ONCE every five years, the Research Assessment Exercise (RAE) can prove both joyful and agonising to UK universities.
RAE 2008, published on 18th December, has continued the tradition. Durham is celebrating yet again, with an outstanding set of scores despite the new marking regime bringing with it confusion and uncertainty.
The RAE was first held in 1986, with this recent assessment being the 6th set of results. The last set of results, published in 2001, cited Durham as one of the most research intensive institutions in the UK.
That has not changed – this time, over 90% of Durham’s departments have been classed as having “internationally renowned” research.
The research is graded by the HEFCE (Higher Education Funding Council England) using a star rating, with four stars for world leading quality, three for internationally excellent, two for recognised internationally, and one for nationally recognised.
The best-performing departments were Maths, Archaeology, Geography, and Theology and Religion, which were also classed as some of the best in the whole country.
All of Durham’s departments scored 50% or above for their research in the top two categories.
Overall, the university came in 17th out of all the UK’s 127 universities, and top in the North East – followed by Newcastle, Northumbria, Teesside and Sunderland respectively.
The method of assessment has caused some confusion. In the past, RAE research was ranked 3, 4 and 5 with 5* being awarded to the most outstanding.
The numbers were also accompanied by either A, B or C, representing the proportion of staff entered to be assessed at each level.
This time however, a percentage has been given for the proportion of total staff entered which attained each ranking.
This has lead to some doubt regarding the proportion of funding each department will receive, especially as it is impossible to compare the results with last year due to the differing marking systems.
In the face of confusion, one thing that is certain is Durham’s continued success.
The university ranks highest out of its 1994 group of universities proportionately, beating the universities of Bath, York and St. Andrews.
The Vice-Chancellor, Professor Chris Higgins, said: “While we are still considering the results and their implications in greater detail, this is a very pleasing outcome that is testament to the excellence and hard work of our academic staff over the last seven years.”
Professor Tom McLeish, Pro Vice-Chancellor for Research, added: “These results are yet another indicator of Durham University’s continually rising position as a leading research university, stemming from the excellence, enthusiasm and energy of our staff.”
In recent years, concerns have emerged regarding the RAE and the need for its reform, resulting in the extended seven year gap between the most recent sets of results. A new system, the Research Excellence Framework, will come into force later this year.
