Reproductive technologies: pregnancy and female autonomy in the 21st century
Content Warning: this article contains discussion of abortion.
By Christian Vince
Dr Chloe Elizabeth Romanis is an assistant professor in Biolaw at Durham Law school, with a research focus in the rights of pregnant individuals and reproductive technology. I came across Dr Romanis in my second year of my law degree in which she gave a series of four lectures discussing the prospect of being able to gestate a human inside an artificial womb. Following the overturning of Roe v Wade and being aware of the many questions that people are asking about its potential encroachment on UK law, I was keen to speak to Dr Romanis about all things pregnancy.
After gaining her undergraduate and masters from the University of Manchester, due to their large medical law department, Dr Romanis enrolled on a PhD at Durham. Following the completion of her PhD mid-pandemic and a couple of years teaching and researching in Durham, Dr Romanis has now started a year-long fellowship at Harvard to write a book on the artificial womb, a reproductive technology discussed later in the article.
As mentioned, I am keen to get an academic’s perspective on the overturning of Roe v Wade and its potential impact on other jurisdictions. One of the central issues raised by Romanis is the “tendency to compare everything to the US”. She eloquently suggests that “almost accidentally, the US gets heralded as the example, when actually abortion rights aren’t good there and they never have been really”. I am interested to hear about how the US came to reach this decision to which Dr Romanis responds that, for a while now, the “abortion right has been slowly chipped away at”. She mentions the development of so-called “abortion deserts”, a name given to large expanses of land with no abortion clinic for miles, making access to abortion more difficult for pregnant individuals in these areas. As a result of this, “you can’t ignore the fact that the vast majority that are going to be impacted by the decision are marginalised groups, particularly black women … poorer people, people living within cities with less good infrastructure”.
Dr Romanis hopes that “instead of looking to the US for examples of a liberal legal abortion right, what we might start doing is thinking about broader questions like access to justice and maybe reflecting on what the US can learn from the situation here”. Dr Romanis caveats this remark by highlighting the pitfalls in the UK laws surrounding abortion. “I don’t think people know that abortion is a crime [in the UK]” and “if it were up to me, we would decriminalise tomorrow”. However, as much as Dr Romanis does not “love the law in the UK, … practically speaking, abortion here is far more accessible and prosecutions are rare”.
Our discussion moves to Romanis’ research into reproductive technologies, namely: the artificial womb. This technology, originally intended as an alternative to current neonatal intensive care, emulates a traditional womb, providing the fetus with oxygen and nutrients needed for full development. I must admit, when I first heard of this technology, my mind darted to a dystopian baby lab like the one in Huxley’s ‘Brave New World’. However, Dr Romanis opened my eyes to this being a positive development as it is “a game changer for those with physiology to become pregnant because it means choices about pregnancy”. When Dr Romanis first came across this development, her thought process was “this is great! I can decide if I want to have a child without having to decide that I want to be pregnant for 9 months”. However, after a moment of thought, Dr Romanis quickly realised the issues that could arise from this development.
The law is always playing catch up with science
Dr Romanis
As a medical law academic, it is Dr Romanis’ job to ensure that the law is ready for this medical development and ensure that potential socio-legal ramifications are considered. “The reality is that the technology as a replacement for neonatal intensive care is coming and we are going to have to start making some really difficult decisions”. Romanis develops, “science has this terrible way of being really quick at developing something that we almost aren’t anticipating so the law is always playing catch up with science”. Currently, the technology has only been tested on lambs however, “the team in Philadelphia are anticipating testing on humans in the next one to five years” which means Dr Romanis’ research is becoming increasingly important.
I ask after the key issues that could arise as a result of this technology being used on humans. A first point is the fact that “there are a lot of people who value [traditional] pregnancy and I worry that if we talk about artificial placentas as a “solution to pregnancy, that completely ignores those other people’s experiences”. Another, scarier prospect is the biobag being used as “a tool for reproductive coercion”. Dr Romanis draws upon the potential capacity for those individuals who are not deemed as being “good enough pregnant people” to have their baby transferred to one of these biobags.
One day, we could imagine a world in which cis-gendered male people might gestate
Dr Romanis
Finally, I enquire after one of Dr Romanis’ most recent projects involving research into assisted gestative technologies, notably: “surrogacy, uterus transplantation and artificial placentas”. We speak mostly about the second area as it is often forgotten as a way in which individuals can have children. “The first target group is biologically female people who are born without a uterus”, of which there are around 100,000 in the UK alone. “Before the first transplantation in 2014, there was no option for people who wanted to get pregnant. You either had to use a surrogate or adopt”. Another target group is those who are not biologically female. “It could be a game changer for people who are transgender and wish to experience certain aspects of the female anatomy that they might not otherwise be able to”. Dr Romanis develops this further, “one day, we could imagine a world in which cis-gendered male people might gestate”.
Dr Romanis’ continued research into these developing issues and her “I go where the emergency takes me” philosophy, will certainly make a massive difference in the way in which society utilises these new and exciting technologies.
Image credit: Bram Saeys

