Report claims private school university applicants have advantage
There have been calls to modify the university applications system following the results of a recent study by The Sutton Trust.
The study examined over 300 personal statements from students with the same exam results at A Level. The researchers suggested that private school pupils are much more likely to have received help from teachers with their personal statements.
It also noted that 70% of private school applicants went on to study at high-ranking universities, compared to 50% of those from state schools.
According to the Complete University Guide 2013, 59% of Durham University undergraduates are state-educated.
Durham University has also published its statistics.
For undergraduate entrants in 2011/12 intake, Hild Bede had highest proportion of students from independent schools, at 53.85%, whereas Josephine Butler had the fewest in Durham (25.33%) and the fewest overall at John Snow in Stockton (22.03%).
The study highlighted that personal statements from state school pupils were three times more likely to contain grammatical errors or informal language compared to their private school counterparts. Personal statements have been deemed as a means to “highlight past advantages.”
Tom Brook, a third year engineer at Cuths, agreed that privately-educated pupils have an unfair advantage.
“Whilst I did receive suggestions to change part of my personal statement, by no means did we receive much more help than that. Whereas, I’ve heard from fellow Durham students that they got much more concentrated support: in some cases, one-on-one tuition in writing it!”
Conversely, Briony Richards, a third year mathematician at Cuths, who attended a state school argued:
“My school was really supportive with personal statements. We were all made to produce drafts which were marked and remarked by our form tutors.”
She added: “However, I was lucky because I went to a small sixth form attached to the school I’d been at since year 7, so the teachers knew me well. Friends of mind who went to bigger sixth forms or colleges weren’t offered any help.”
The Sutton Trust, a charity for the promotion of social mobility, has called for new rules with regards to personal statements, such as limiting the number of work experience activities and the prevention of submitting identical statements for more than one applicant.
The study also showed that privately-educated pupils were more likely to cite high-profile work experience placements such as Magic Circle law firms, luxury five-star hotels and City traders. On the other hand, state school pupils cited Saturday jobs and school-organised trips to local businesses.
The Chief Executive of UCAS, Mary Curnock Cook, commended the findings in the report. However, she also reiterated her confidence in the admissions procedure, stating that admissions officers “are highly experienced in recognising social factors in the content of personal statements.”

