Report cards to show student achievement
EIGHTEEN BRITISH UNIVERSITIES are to pilot a new system of reports cards which could eventually replace the traditional degree classification system of awarding firsts, 2.1s and 2.2s.
The new Higher Education Achievement Report (HEAR) proposes to give a more comprehensive account ofa student’s achievements, both academic and extra-curricular.
Certain students at the institutions trialling HEAR, will receive a transcript with individual marks and a record of additional information which could be useful to employers, such as details of work experience or time spent studying abroad.
The scheme is subject to an evaluation in February 2009 and if deemed a success, will see existing students of these universities given report cards when they graduate next year. The evaluation in February will be judged by both employers and students, as well as the institutions themselves, and it is hoped that other universities will incorporate the scheme in 2010-11.
It is intended that the reports would be awarded to supplement the traditional final degree classification rather than replace it entirely.
The scheme is a result of a report issued by the Burgess Group, which led an inquiry into the degree classification system. It concluded that the old system was a ‘blunt tool,’ with its leader, the vice-chancellor of the University of Leicester, Professor Robert Burgess, arguing that university assessments needed to develop over time just as the university curriculum has. One of the key aims is to provide employers with a more accurate view of a student’s intellectual and personal abilities, given that over 300,000 students now graduate from British institutions with bachelors degrees every year. Two thirds of this number achieve a first or 2.1.
The current grading system for universities has recently been described as no longer ‘fit for purpose’ by Aaron Porter, National Union of Students vice-President for higher education, who argues that: “Students deserve a more detailed acknowledgement of their achievement from their time in higher education.”
Professor Burgess would like students to eventually receive report cards at the end of their degree. He did however add that it was very unlikely the current classification system would be removed within the next few years.
