Remembering the Holocaust
Shoah is undoubtedly one of the most important films of all time. Its reputation, both as a work of art and as a historical document, is firmly secured within the academic community. However, as far as the general public is concerned, it might as well not exist.
The reasons for the film’s relative obscurity are obvious: a nine-hour documentary on the Holocaust is not something with immediate marketable appeal to a mass audience. Take in to account the fact that the film uses no archive footage and no musical score, and it becomes even clearer why this vitally important film remains, for the most part, unseen.
And yet, it is all of the factors which make Claude Lanzmann’s 1985 film ‘unappealing’ to filmgoers, which provide its power. The lack of music lends it a ghostly atmosphere as the camera leads us unbearably slowly through the remnants of Auschwitz; and, by ignoring any archive footage, Lanzmann roots the film firmly in the present, implying both that the Holocaust is still all around us, and also that we must never forget it.
However, Lanzmann’s greatest skill as a documentary filmmaker is his interviewing technique. In what is perhaps the film’s most moving scene, Lanzmann interviews Abraham Bomba, who survived the concentration camps simply because, as a barber, he could be used to cut the hair of Jewish women before they entered the gas chambers. When Bomba breaks down after recalling that he had to cut the hair of his friend’s wife moments before her death, Lanzmann urges him on, telling him “We have to do it.” What may seem like unnecessary cruelty is in fact a desire to capture history. Both Lanzmann and the survivors he interviews “know it’s very hard”, but equally acknowledge that it’s very necessary.
Lanzmann further demonstrates his courage as a filmmaker by tracking down several Nazi officials and secretly filming his conversations with them. Through these rare and remarkable perspectives on ‘the final solution’ it becomes clear that few of the perpetrators were aware of the big picture. That is not to say that they were not criminals: Franz Suchomel, who was a guard at Treblinka, mentions, with almost a sense of pride, that women were not beaten as they were driven into the gas chambers; to which Lanzmann questions, with an irony lost on his interviewee, “Why such humanity?”
Shoah is ultimately a film that transcends its definition as a historical documentary. Lanzmann himself even acknowledged that, “Making a history was not what I wanted to do. I wanted to construct something more powerful than that”. And scenes such as the one where Micahaël Podchlebnik, one of only two survivors from Chelmno, explains simply that “if you’re alive it’s better to smile” prove that Lanzmann did create something with truly great emotional power. Podchlebnik’s comments seem to sum up the infinite value of human life, and demonstrate the remarkable power of the human spirit.
For this reason, among others, Shoah is a film that falls into the oversubscribed category of ‘timeless’, and I urge you to watch it. To quote David Denby’s original review in New York Magazine: “Reading about this movie isn’t enough: you must see it.”

