Reforms to University applications would be very welcome
If university is going to cost students three times as much, at least the government is finally making steps in the direction of ensuring the fairness of the admissions procedure. The recent announcement (in an unpublished White Paper) that students will now be able to apply to university after receiving their A-Level results is very welcome. For those who missed the story, overshadowed as it was by the news from Tunisia, Brazil and Australia, the paper will suggest that university terms begin in January and exams are taken some weeks earlier than they are now. Furthermore, this raises the possibility of the first year of a degree being shortened, a welcome cost-cutting measure. After all, the point of that year is to find your feet and get used to university; why drag out the process when two terms would suffice? The most significant change will be the end of predicted grades, a staggering half of which are currently proved incorrect. Many private schools give their students a huge advantage by over-predicting their grades, with schools like my own eager to make A* predictions.
Additionally, the current system punishes those who do poorly on their AS Levels. Poor results lead to poor predictions, poor predictions to a lack of offers, which hardly encourages effort at A2. Instead, the Year 12 slacker-slash-party animal can now be rewarded for pulling his proverbial socks up in his A-levels, rather than be dragged down by his teacher’s lack of confidence in him.
If innovation is taking place, is it not time to end the farcical concept that is the personal statement? Certainly the moniker is incorrect: it is far from personal, usually being subjected to the advice and rewrites of parents, teachers and friends, and it is a less of a statement than a flagrant boast. The content of a typical statement, which often revolves around why the applicant wishes to study their chosen subject, is frankly ridiculous. The simple and often true answer, that the student likes the subject, is never enough. One wonders if admissions tutors grow tired of reading a thousand variations of “I like maths”.
Replacing the personal statement with an aptitude test tailored to degree programmes (especially in subjects not offered at A-level) would provide a much better indicator of ability.
This announcement of earlier exams, while momentous, is hardly innovative. Most European countries, as well as the USA, apply with grades in hand. Why has the UK, a country supposedly famed for its higher education, lagged so far behind? The coalition will no doubt blame the previous government; certainly they must be blamed for lack of legislation making declaring AS level results compulsory, rather than the current system which allows a student gaining, for example, three Cs at AS to be predicted three As for their UCAS form.
Arguably it is irrelevant who to pin the blame on in this case, more important is ensuring those who deserve to gain places at their desired (and soon-to-be-horribly-overpriced) universities. Are Messrs Gove and Willetts finally getting their act together as the men in charge of our education? However, the paper will not even be published until spring, debated endlessly, and, if passed, the reforms would have to wait at least two years to avoid disruption to existing students.
As per usual, the British government is happy to take its time (Crossrail, for example, was proposed in 1989- it will be supposedly completed in 2018) when there is no financial reward involved.

