Reflective Education

By Rohan Banerjee

While The Independent hasgrammar schools

taken to publishing articles about kidnapped llamas to speed up their slow news days, it seems that the broadsheets in this country remain a slave to something a little more high brow. Platforming a debate that’s so old it probably shares a birthday with Bruce Forsyth, Tim Wigmore’s latest piece on grammar schools in The Daily Telegraph has opened up the usual furore over classism and the Eleven Plus.

As it’s been a similarly slow week here at Features, I thought I’d offer my two cents on something I’ve already donated more than a dollar’s worth to over the years. In fact, I wrote my undergraduate dissertation on social mobility through schooling.

The silver spoon fed product of a grammar school myself, I had initially viewed reinstating these now endangered red brick creatures, as something of a panacea for Britain’s educational gulf.

Since completing my dissertation, however, I’ve become far less naive. The sheer cost of such a move would be enormous, while the process of selection itself is misguided; such is the Eleven Plus’ unforgiving rigidity, that many late bloomers could be overlooked. Group this with the fact that there are a number of top performing non-selective state schools and the case for a Tripartite system loses considerable momentum. For example, Thomas Telford School, a comprehensive in Shropshire, boasts a 98% pass rate at GCSE.

Yet, wading into this quagmire of angry parents and even angrier journalists, I still consider myself to be for the most part ‘pro’ grammar. If the existence of some top performing comps is a stitch in the grammar’s side, then the fact that “England was ranked 22nd for literacy and 21st for numeracy out of 24 OECD countries,” (Wigmore) is definitely its second wind. There are only 164 grammar schools still in operation today, which means Britain’s poor performance is linked more with widespread comprehensives.

Although I’ve already conceded that selection is a bad thing, barring Thomas Telford and a few others, it’s clear to see that the comprehensive system has not worked as well as the 1965 Labour government would have hoped. Moreover, The Daily Telegraph reported in January that as many as 170,000 pupils were at state schools found to be ‘failing’ by Ofsted.

By contrast, the majority of the minority educated by grammar schools are regular infiltrators of The Russell Group and beyond. Indeed, if we adopt leavers’ destinations as a proxy, then the grammars stand out. Simon Langton Grammar School in Canterbury has sent over 150 students to The Russell Group in the last five years; while Dr. Challoner’s Grammar School in Amersham has an annual Oxbridge admissions average exceeding double digits.

So, how can I be simultaneously against selection, yet critical of comprehensives? Just as grammar schools are not necessarily successful because of selection, most comprehensives are not necessarily unsuccessful because they don’t have an entrance exam. The answer lies in something far more complex – that is the qualitative notion of pastoral care.

What Wigmore dismisses as “emotion and anecdote” or what The Guardian’s Fiona Millar attributes to “elitism,” is actually the biggest difference between selective and non-selective state education. Cast aside the Eleven Plus for a moment and consider something that most grammar schools have in common – infastructural parallels with the private sector.

Visiting my own alma mater recently, I stood in the oak-beamed dining hall, admiring the honours boards that hung proudly on the walls. My school was not a private school, but it was every bit as good as one, and it cost my parents absolutely nothing.

There was a competitive house structure and a set of ties to recognise different achievements, all part of a healthy culture of prestige. The school sent students of all backgrounds to the country’s leading universities and rivalled the local private schools in examination results ably.

However, the charter for much of comprehensive education is one bogged down by a misjudged ode to a mangled post-modernity. So much of the case for comprehensives or garishly prefrabbed sixth form colleges relies on reversing tradition; but that’s exactly where they’re going wrong.

In axing house systems or neglecting extra curricular activities, many comprehensives risk succumbing to the facelessness of standardisation. It’s as much psychological as anything else if there’s no motivation to excel.

Interestingly though, of the non-selective state schools that do perform well, four of the top five achievers recognised by last year’s league tables in The Independent, employed a competitive house system, while all five placed a huge emphasis on alumni links after leaving.

Further down the line, if we look at the most successful universities, both Oxford and Cambridge are built on very pastoral structures. Considering this, is it any wonder that our very own similarly collegiate university was recently found to have the best quality of life for students by a national newspaper?

I digress. It’s not the Eleven Plus that facilitates social mobility – if anything, that obscures it with certain parents being able to afford tuition – but nothing can be taken away from the benefits of a grammar’s educational style, which is committed to providing a structured and aspirational ethos about the school. In the case of children whose parents are not necessarily academic themselves, this goes a long way toward bridging that gap.

Still, for my own part, don’t think there’s any incoherence in coming from grammar school stock and simultaneously opposing selection. I am privileged enough to have benefited from seven years of first-class education, and to deny that opportunity to others seems profoundly immoral.

Chronicling my journey from advocate to apologist has been fun, but now I feel I should offer some solution. I suggest a compromised system that embraces all the framework of a grammar school without practicing selection.

And my ideological hybrid is not as incompatible as perhaps it sounds. Toby Young’s West London Free School is a giant step in the right direction of changing how state education is delivered. We should not underestimate the benefits of structure, nor shy away from the perceived primness of it all. There’s a reason Eton’s boy run societies have produced so many politicians. There’s a reason why schools with active debating societies produce so many lawyers.

Tim Wigmore is right to point out the failings of selection, but I won’t stand for any slight against the merits of a grammar school. For more information visit: www.westlondonfreeschool.co.uk

Photos by Paul Downey