Reflections from a year abroad
By Samuel John
Being part of the first generation to experience higher tuition fees, the scrapping of student grants, and (in Durham), the seemingly endless increase in accommodation fees, it seems that now more than ever, students have a right to expect some sort of ‘value for money’ when it comes to their degrees. Sadly, for a large number of Durham students, particularly undergraduates studying social sciences and humanities, this is simply not the case.
I am completely bemused as to exactly how the social sciences faculty at Durham has jumped up to 36th on world rankings. Having experienced a year’s study at the University of Amsterdam and being exposed to the ‘European Approach’ to higher education, I increasingly think that undergraduates in the non-sciences are being swindled. Next year, undergraduates in catered accommodation will be expected to pay £7,000 a year (a figure that would make the leader of a racketeering ring blush). Alongside this comes the revelation that Durham University has spent a bewildering £2.6 million on ‘artwork’ over the last five years, thus indirectly depriving potential undergraduates from lower income backgrounds a place at university in favour of a group of morbid statues outside the Bill Bryson library that make Edvard Munch’s ‘The Scream’ look cheerful, and a collection of no doubt equally wonderful pieces in the Palatine centre that the vast majority of students will never even have the pleasure of seeing.
So, for a university that (naturally) charges the full tuition fee of £9,000 and accommodation fees of £7,000, where is the substance to match its expensive, gloomy-art-obsessed style? Durham, like other UK universities in its relation to social sciences and humanities, is big on ‘independent learning’. Of course,’ independent learning’ is a necessary part of our degrees; more commonly known as ‘reading’, it is an important supplement to the core content of the lecturers and the discussions of tutorials and seminars. However, through Orwellian re-branding of the word ‘reading’ to ‘independent learning’, the University has effectively replaced what was formerly a supplement to actual contact with staff. On average, we receive a handful of lectures of 45 minutes apiece, and fortnightly tutorials of a similar length, in which the lecturers themselves remain absent until final year. I don’t mean to criticise the PhD students that end up leading the seminars in first and second years, but at the very least should students not expect that the lecturers at least try to make an appearance in these tutorials, even if they are unable to lead every single session?
For a point of reference, at the University of Amsterdam, each social sciences module offers a minimum lecture and seminar length of 2 hours, with both a lecture and a seminar every week. In this setting, lectures feel more natural; they are not sticking to a strict PowerPoint plan that they churn out every year (with the odd slide revealing a slip in detail that suggests it hasn’t been updated in years); they deliver the core content but also are given space to relate to their own areas of expertise and provide insightful personal and empirical examples to reinforce it. Longer seminar lengths also allow a much more in-depth exploration of the content of the relevant readings and what has been outlined in the relevant lecture. It also enables the development of a rapport within the group itself, and between them and the tutor, who is nearly always a working lecturer or professor.
Contrast this to certain departments in Durham, and you get a much bleaker picture. Tutorials are often perpetually out of sync with lectures due to their fortnightly nature, which develops less of an engaging rapport with other students and more of a misty acknowledgement of recognition between yourself and other students you see for about forty minutes every second Tuesday. For any poor souls that live out ‘beyond the wall’ in Gilesgate, a 45-minute walk to the crooked Elvet Hill House (an obscure appendage of the politics department which resembles more a warren of frightened rabbits tripping up over uneven floorboards than a buzzing centre of academic rigour) is rewarded with around 45 minutes of discussion that is either strained and vacuous or engaging and potentially truly insightful yet cut short before anything meaningful can actually occur, after which we are sent on our merry way back to Gilesgate, constituting a journey twice the length (and maybe even twice the quality) of the class we’ve attended.
Durham University deludes itself. Despite being populated by a significant number of Oxbridge rejects, being ‘old and pretty’ and having colleges, it is not Oxford, and it is not Cambridge. Yet it operates its term dates and length along similar lines. What makes Durham noticeably less Oxbridge-like is its lack of contact hours in relation to this term time. Term starts, after Fresher’s and ‘introductory’ lectures and classes, realistically halfway through October, with a ‘Christmas’ break of a month (that starts bizarrely close to Christmas day), and a third ‘term’ that is essentially a stress-inducing joke that crams everyone with exams and deadlines and then leaves the entire student population in limbo for month wondering why the hell the last few weeks had to be so rushed.
I am not trying to demonise lecturers; it’s not that every lecturer at Durham starts suffering brain aneurisms at the 50-minute mark from the debilitating sound of their own droning and so is physically unable or unwilling to continue. But there is an underlying systematic problem here; one that charges students an increasingly extortionate amount to attend, while simultaneously placing academic staff under the pressure to churn out research to be deemed ‘profitable’, thus distancing the experts from the people that are paying about £50 for an hour of their erudite presence, in lectures that feel rushed and overly routine, resulting in the academic neglect of students, particularly in their first and second years. So, to surmise, it seems indeed that a significant portion of Durham students are getting less value for more money.
Photograph: Iijjccoo at nl.wikipedia via Wikimedia Commons
