Refereeing protocols against racism in football
By Marcia Costa
On the 17th of February the Benfica vs Real Madrid game in Lisbon was paused for 11 minutes. The interruption came after forward Vinicius Junior alleged to referee Letexier that a racist comment had been made towards him by Benfica player Gianluca Prestianni. Letexier crossed his arms in a “X” shape above his head symbolising that FIFA’s anti-racism protocol had started. The protocol was introduced in 2024 with the aim of empowering both players and referees to stand up to racism.
Though the protocol marks a positive step forward in how the sport handles incidents of racism, the effectiveness has since been questioned. The protocol follows 3 steps. The first is the X mark that can be used by the referees, the players and any competition officials. The protocol also gives referees the power to pause the match if they find reason to do so.
Secondly, the match is suspended if the issue is not resolved during the pause. Lastly if no real solution to the incident can be found the match will be abandoned. The protocol was deployed after Vinicius Junior ran to the referee alleging racism. This came after Vinicius scored against Benfica at the end of the first half. The goal was followed by a celebration which landed the Brazilian a yellow card. Prestianni could be seen with his shirt covering his mouth, a move which caused former Manchester City player Micah Richards to label him a “coward”. Vinicius later alleged that he heard Prestianni use a racist slur five times. Though the game was paused for eleven minutes, no real solution was found and the game continued as normal. This has caused people to question if the protocol was truly trying to tackle racism or if it is purely performative as Prestianni was still allowed to play.
Though the protocol marks a positive step forward… the effectiveness has since been questioned
Since the game the media has exploded with fury over the incident. Real player Kylian Mbappé called for Prestianni to be banned from future Champions League games with the team’s goalkeeper Thibaut Courtois saying that the team would have walked out of the match if Vinicius decided he did not want to continue with the game anymore. Anger over not only the incident but also the reaction of Benfica manager Jose Mourinho has sparked significant controversy. In a post-match interview Mourinho claimed that Vinicius’ goal celebration provoked Prestianni. Former Liverpool player Jamie Carragher responded to Mourinho’s statement by highlighting that Mourinho himself consistently celebrates and antagonises the opposition “probably more than any coach has ever done”. Whilst Prestianni and Benfica have since consistently denied the incident, a suspension was given to the Argentine who was not allowed to play during the second leg of the round.
Alongside controversy the incident has also sparked debate over the effectiveness of the FIFA anti-racism protocol. In a statement shared to his Instagram story Vinicius claimed that the protocol was “poorly executed” and “served no purpose”. Sanjay Bhandari, chair of organisation Kick It Out, (an organisation that aims to tackle discrimination in football), expressed his dissatisfaction with the policy which he believes is the majority opinion. Bhandari also acknowledged, however, the fact that at present there is no alternative solution to the issue. According to the protocol given by FIFA the accused player can only be removed from a game if the referee has heard the abuse, aside from that the referee has no power to remove the player. Bhandari pointed out a further flaw in the protocol in that no player would say something offensive in the earshot of a referee.
There is no alternative solution to the issue
The conclusion seems to be that the protocol, though a clear stand to racism in football, is flawed with gaps that make it difficult to properly address racism. The incident that happened highlights that while the protocol temporarily stalled the game and gave Real Madrid an opportunity to support their teammate, the protocol was futile in truly holding Prestianni accountable. This was mainly due to structural issues that restrict the powers of the referees. With the investigation ongoing the footballing world is now waiting to see what the verdict on Prestianni will be and whether the protocol will truly come to Vinicius’ defence.
Image by Planet_fox via Pixabay

