Red Line? Syria’s long past that

by Al Russell
The recent allegations of the use of chemical weapons by the Assad regime have given rise to a rhetoric of “red lines.” Both Obama and Cameron have stated in interviews that if these allegations prove to be true, which seems all but certain, it represents the straw that broke the camel’s back for the Assad regime.
However, the camel’s back has long been broken in Syria. It is true that the use of chemical weapons against the population would constitute an abhorrent war crime, but the civil war in Syria has been a catalogue of war crimes; chemical weapons do not represent a game-changer.
The direct targeting of civilians by government forces, irrespective of their revolutionary affiliations, has been well documented in Syria in the two years since the conflict began in the ‘Arab Spring’ of 2011. Therefore it cannot be argued that only now is Assad crossing a ‘red line.’ The concept of sovereign responsibility has been made a mockery of in Syria, and the reaction of the western liberal democracies so keen to act as the world’s moral compass has been equally pitiable.
The debate over intervention in Syria is undeniably more complex than simply weighing up the cosmopolitan idealism of western politicians. The increasingly Islamist make-up of opposition forces is pushing many towards a ‘better the devil you know’ outlook and the geopolitical environment in the region makes any involvement potentially catastrophic. These circumstances have not changed, if anything they have worsened.
However, in conceding that the use of chemical weapons would constitute a bridge too far in Syria, Cameron and Obama are making an implicit judgement that the ‘lesser’ evils of the conflict to date weren’t worth their involvement. The international community has a legitimate responsibility to protect the Syrian population from the war crimes of its regime, and if the conflict was, until now, too complex for third party involvement, then the possibility of this changing due to ‘higher ranking’ war crimes is, at best, hypocritical. If western intervention is appropriate in the light of these recent discoveries then it was appropriate eighteen months ago, and all the deaths that have occurred in the interim have been needless.
Nothing has changed in Syria but the seriousness of the allegations and it seems worryingly as if western governments are concerned not with whether or not Assad choses to murder his country’s population, but rather with the means that he employs to do so.
Photograph: Freedom House
