Reason for the season: historical depictions of the classical Nativity scene

By Amrita Sura

The Renaissance period embodied a transformative commitment to the rebirth of antiquity and immense artistic and technological advancement. As such, it provided an apt canvas for artists concerned with Christian iconography, in particular, explorations of the Nativity scene as seen as a rebirth of mankind through Christ’s humble beginnings. From its beginnings in the cultural legacy in 1223 with Saint Francis Assisi’s living recreation, this tableau quickly made its way to the realm of painters, and by the 14th century was popular within the works of Italian artists. Drawn in by the intimacy of new birth, and the paradox of divinity revered and mortal maternalism, these devotional pieces charm artists and viewers alike, regardless of their religious affinities. 

Moving away from Byzantine depictions of the Nativity set in a cave, the Renaissance introduced, with the work of Giotto, the intimate stable Nativity. Geertegen tot Sint Jans’ The Nativity at Night invites the viewer themselves into this newly established intimacy. As a small devotional painting it encourages believers to contemplate the scene as a means to transform themselves in Christ’s image. The early Dutch painting was likely commissioned for a convent, and with this assumption the establishment of a female audience provides a unique lens through which the painting can be analysed. The crafting of Mary with clasped hands and lit face is celebratory in its vulnerability, she is presented as not simply a vehicle for Christ’s conception but holds the attention of both her shining son and the viewer. Sint Jans foregoes the tradition swaddle and instead, inspired by the visions of Saint Bridget of Sweden, depicts him naked and emitting his own divine light. The painting was one of the first pieces of Northern art to realistically depict night; it is so dark; the faces of Joseph and the stable’s animals are cast into background shadow. Lit in the foreground instead, are awestruck angels, the maternal love of Mary, and the viewer. The clever composition allows space in the foreground for an outside viewer to take part in the Biblical scene they would likely be all too familiar with. Having the darkest tones of the painting in the immediate foreground and far background allow the palette to retain its intimacy, veering away from cool blacks and standing resolutely warm. It is therefore never concerned with the cold, unsheltered setting or the imagined fear and loneliness of Mary’s labour but imbues its depiction with the spiritual perfection it invites its viewer into. 

The paradox of divinity revered alongside mortal materialism

As an exemplary piece of the High Renaissance, Albrecht DĂĽrer’s Adoration of the Magi mixes both Nordic models and Italian influences in an equally innovative 16th century advancement to the Nativity. The painting’s rich tonal qualities offset Christ’s modesty, instead connoting the power and influence he will soon hold. Deep ultramarines form the fabric of Mary’s dress, intensifying the paleness of her and her son. This serves to suggest a divine radiance emanating from the two, even when it is not explicitly present. The painting perfectly embodies the Renaissance values of advancement and revival in its technical rendering; fabrics, jewels, and brickwork are executed in intricate detail even far into the background. The Romanesque buildings connote the Holy Land and antiquity, their ruin emphasising the destabilising force of Christ, but through DĂĽrer’s attention to detail he mediates the Renaissance paradox of antique revival and innovation, in allowing them to retain their grandeur despite their destruction. Rebirth is furthered in the compositional reimagining of the typical scene, utilising an outdoor landscape focused less on newborn intimacy but rather the bright vivacity of the promise of change. 

Beginning the transition from Renaissance to Baroque, Caravaggio’s Adoration of the Shepherds is the most emotionally impactful of these Nativity scenes. Bathed in red tones, the painting is at odds with the typical conventions of the Nativity by foregoing tender light for unapologetic heat. It oozes the visceral emotion of immediate birth, employing chiaroscuro in its light contrast to further its drama. Mary’s slumped position and the carnality of the red’s saturation means the viewer cannot separate Christ’s divine perfection from the physicality of his birth. With a background that appears almost unfinished, the viewer’s eye is anchored to the central figures in an echo of architectural ruin that imbues the piece with the simplicity of maternal love. 

Evocative intimacy entices both artists and viewers

The intimacy and warmth of the Nativity scene stands as a staunch rebellion against the barren winter landscape. It is no surprise that it is a concept revisited constantly throughout time as its evocative intimacy entices both artists and viewers alike. In its Renaissance conception, the scene represents both the renewing properties of Christ and the period itself, they work harmoniously as subject and context in a way which cannot be replicated. 

Image: Wikimedia Commons