Ranking the Marvel Cinematic Universe

By Joshua Peters

Guardians of the Galaxy marks the tenth entry in the Marvel Cinematic Universe, the studio’s attempt to craft an interlinked superhero world. Presented here are our rankings of the films, from worst to best. 

10.  Iron Man 3: Whilst Tony Stark’s third outing is a perfectly serviceable blockbuster, with a set piece on-board and around Air Force One a particular highlight, as an Iron Man film, Shane Black’s work is ultimately a failure.

The titular Iron Man Suit’s infrequent appearances are made all the more frustrating by its seemingly diminished power, as technology once capable of fighting Thor can now be defeated by enemies as diverse and deadly as slowly moving traffic. With films such as Guardians of the Galaxy demonstrating the importance of soundtracks in establishing tone, the absence of AC/DC  is all the more representative of the film’s lack of personality.

With the suitably frightening Ben Kingsley, terrific as the villain in the film Sexy Beast, playing the Bin Laden-esque Mandarin, a villain teased since the first movie, fans were promised an exciting change of pace from the typical corporate entities faced by Stark in his first two films. Yet, once again, by the film’s climax, owing to an utterly disappointing twist which sees Kingsley wasted in a thankless comedic role, Stark is facing off against Guy Pearce’s bland corporate executive, whose vaguely defined fire-related powers do little to restore excitement to proceedings.

9.     Iron Man 2: Ben Kingsley wasn’t the first talented actor wasted by Marvel, with Mickey Rourke similarly sidelined as villain Whiplash. Though the actor trained rigorously, going as far as to spend time in a Russian prison to learn the dialect, most of his character’s back-story remained on the cutting room floor.

Rourke’s role was a casualty of Marvel’s over-eagerness to build the wider Cinematic Universe, with Scarlett Johansson’s Black Widow and Samuel L. Jackson’s Nick Fury fleshed out during the film’s running time. These plot additions are made all the more superfluous by the fact that Whedon’s Avengers eventually dismissed multiple plot points established by the film, treating Black Widow as a new character and ultimately ignoring Stark’s dismissal from the Avengers Initiative.

Though the resultant story is at times a mess, Iron Man 2 succeeds over the third film by sheer force of its personality, with Robert Downey Jnr’s performance as Stark, an egomaniac genius coming face to face with his own mortality carrying the film. The fact that Rourke’s assault on the Monaco Grand Prix stands as the best action scene in the Iron Man franchise doesn’t hurt either.

Hulk8.     The Incredible Hulk: Though Batman Begins’ success ensured that the ‘darker, grittier’ reboot model became a Hollywood staple, the underperformance of The Incredible Hulk at the box office sadly condemned the movie-going public to the rehashed origin stories of the likes of The Amazing Spiderman.

Louis Letterier’s decision to reference Banner’s origins in the credits, before telling a new story, stands as one of the reboots many successes. The casting of a suitably intense Edward Norton, and some truly spectacular action scenes, particularly Bruce’s escape through a favela ensures that the film serves as a vast improvement over Ang Lee’s plodding, tiresome 2003 film.

Despite this, the movie’s climax is a disappointment. Whilst the Hulk’s earlier confrontations with human adversaries, led by a menacing Tim Roth, are tightly directed and effectively visceral, the CGI-heavy final confrontation between a digital Hulk and similarly computer generated Abomination is ultimately too cartoony to be in any way engaging.

Thorposter7.     Thor: Whilst the concept of a movie centred on a god-like, humanoid alien with a magical space hammer is likely to provoke sniggers, the decision to populate Thor with classically trained actors such as Anthony Hopkins, and the then unknown Tom Hiddleston, and the choice of Kenneth Branagh as director, provide the film with a grandiose, Shakespearean atmosphere, elevating the film beyond its ultimately silly origins. Chris Hemsworth as the arrogant but noble Thor and Hiddleston as his Machiavellian brother Loki provide real gravitas, with the chemistry between the two actors granting weight to proceedings.

Thor’s journey to Earth provides plenty of great fish out of water comedy moments, though the sheer speed with which he falls for Natalie Portman’s’ astrophysicist and learns the value of humility, even in a film featuring magical space portals, is fairly ridiculous. Hawkeye’s introduction is also somehow more inconsequential than Black Widow’s in Iron Man 2, an achievement in itself.

Thor_-_The_Dark_World_poster6.     Thor: The Dark World: Ironically for a film with such a clear sense of scale, the original Thor’s climax was underwhelming, with the levelling of a small town constituting nothing more than the collapse of a few obvious facades. The sequel rectifies this, with the Dark Elf assault on Asgard and final battle in Greenwich providing set pieces worthy of the mighty Asgardian.

However, the primary villain is once again overlooked and despite Christopher Eccelston’s presence as the villainous Malekith, Tom Hiddleston’s scheming trickster steals the film, with Loki’s attempts to escape imprisonment and seize the throne infinitely more interesting than Malekthis’s one-dimensional quest for the Aether, the movie’s requisite McGuffin.

Thor’s comrades, entertainingly portrayed by Ray Stevenson, Zachary Levi and Jaimie Alexander shine during the standout prison breakout sequence, but are otherwise overlooked, and the Earth-based characters, led by Natalie Portman, continue to serve as little more than plot devices and comic relief. Despite this, the well-staged action, balanced with moments of levity and Marvel’s best cameo since Iron Man’s post credit scene elevate the film beyond its predecessor.

CaptainAmericaFirst5.     Captain America – The First Avenger: The First Avenger is a film of two halves. The first – an utterly unique, retro throwback to the golden age of Marvel Comics, a jingoistic, wholesome superhero film about a little kid from Brooklyn’s path towards greatness. The second is fairly standard good versus evil fare, with Captain America pitted against Hugo Weaving’s villainous Red Skull.

The first half is where the film undoubtedly triumphs, with the characters among the best in any Marvel film. Chris Evans shines as the titular Captain, imbuing his Boy Scout hero with enough warmth, charm and goodness to make an otherwise dull character thoroughly likeable. He is ably supported by a wicked Tommy Lee Jones as an aggressive army Colonel, Stanley Tucci as a sensitive but brilliant scientist and Hayley Atwell as the Cap’s feisty love interest.

The film ultimately suffers in the sagging middle segment, with the Captain stuck in story limbo, neither loveable weakling, nor the action hero he needs to be. Also disappointing is the fact that director Joe Johnston stages the majority of the action in a single montage sequence, with the climatic battle also over far too quickly. However, the final scenes between Atwell and Evans, as he sacrifices himself for the good of America, are among the most powerful in the Cinematic Universe, restoring the film as one of Marvel’s best.

GuardiansoftheGalaxy4.     Guardians of the Galaxy: From the moment Chris Pratt’s charming Star Lord swaggers into an ancient temple to the beat of Redbone’s 1974 hit Come and Get Your Love, using all manner of space fauna as props, it becomes clear that Marvel is onto a winner. Dismissed by many before its release for its utterly ridiculous premise, Director James Gunn confounded expectation by making audiences fall in love with his Guardians of the Galaxy, an ensemble film almost unique in the sense that each of the characters can lay claim to being the film’s heart, soul, and comedic relief. Pratt’s arrogant Star Lord, Zoe Saldana’s deadly Gamora, Dave Bautista’s dense Drax the Destroyer, Bradley Coopers sardonic Rocket Racoon and Vin Diesel’s loveable tree Groot are all given their own moments to shine, and Drax’s inability to understand metaphor as well as the relationship between Rocket and Groot provide many of the film’s funniest moments.

The film also takes time to mock everything from ‘the jackasses standing in a circle’ scene in Avengers Assemble to Jackson Pollock paintings. Villains Ronan the Accuser and Nebula are underdeveloped, though nevertheless physically imposing, with the brilliant practical make up effects worthy of praise. The final battle also suffers for being the sixth in the Marvel Universe to involve a crashing airship, though the viewer will likely be having too much fun to care. Guardians is also crucial in building the mythology of the universe, developing the Infinity Stones arc and fleshing out big bad Thanos in time for Avengers 3.

IronManPoster3.     Iron Man: The first, and only great Iron Man film launched the Marvel Cinematic Universe, transforming both the character and Robert Downey Jnr into A-listers. Downey Jnr blurs the lines between acting and reality, drawing on personal experience to offer subtle hints of the darkness lying underneath the surface of his genius, playboy personality. With its blend of comedy, action, and with the sweet relationship between Stark and Gwyneth Paltrow’s Pepper Potts, at the movie’s heart, Jon Favreau’s film established the tone for the rest of the Cinematic Universe.

The first half in particular is brilliant, with Stark kidnapped by terrorists in Afghanistan, building an early version of the suit from scrap to stage a brilliant escape. Backed up by a fantastic hard rock soundtrack and a charismatic performance from Jeff Bridges as the villain, and let down only by a fairly standard final battle, Iron Man, both in 2008 and still today stands as one of Marvel’s most consistent offerings, with Samuel L. Jackson’s post-credits  appearance as Nick Fury offering the first hint at Marvel head Kevin Feige’s master plan.
 
avengers-assemble-the-avengers-gets-new-title-and-official-poster-81282-470-752.     Avengers Assemble: From Mark Ruffalo’s introduction as the new Hulk to Thor, Captain America and Iron Man’s three way fight in the forest, to the long, tracking shot sequence of the Avengers working against the Chitauri invasion, Joss Whedon’s Avengers Assemble constitutes one crowd pleasing moment after another. Each of the Avengers, except for Hawkeye, the perennial runt of the group, is given ample screen time by Whedon’s script, which crackles with his trademark humour and wit.

The overall flimsiness of the story, which sees an asinine Loki deliberately have himself captured to draw together the only people capable of stopping him, and the occasional lack of cohesiveness with previous films (Thor magically appears on Earth despite the Bifrost’s destruction at the end of the first film) leave plenty of room for sequel Age of Ultron to best its predecessor. Yet, despite its flaws, Avengers Assemble ranks so highly due to the strength of its character arcs, with the conflicts and resolutions between the main characters a source of continued, unadulterated joy.

In making Avengers Assemble, building on existing, beloved characters, Joss Whedon only had to not fail to succeed. Thankfully, he did more than coast on the success of others, crafting a unique cinematic experience that has permanently changed the genre, with Fox, Sony and DC/Warner Bros scrambling to assemble their own Cinematic Universes.

Captain-America-The-Winter-Soldier1.     Captain America – The Winter Soldier: The second Captain America film is one of the best superhero films ever produced, once again boasting some of the finest performances in the Marvel franchise. Every line uttered by Samuel L. Jackson’s permanently belligerent Nick Fury is golden, and Anthony Mackie’s sidekick Falcon; along with Johansson’s Black Widow similarly deserve praise for their likeable performances.

Whilst Captain America was somewhat underpowered in First Avenger and Avengers Assemble, directors Joe and Anthony Russo prove adept at portraying his enhanced abilities in a series of bone crunchingly intense action sequences. A brawl between Rogers and multiple assailants in an elevator, and the attempted assassination of Nick Fury midway through the film stand as the best fight scenes in the Cinematic Universe.

The film also succeeds where most other Marvel films have failed, in the strength of its villains. The Winter Soldier is an unstoppable force, with his appearances, heralded by a frightening, droning musical motif, never failing to wreak unimaginable chaos, as the film’s protagonists are repeatedly stabbed, beaten and shot in a series of genuinely intense struggles for survival. Similarly brilliant is Robert Redford, playing against type as the shady Alexander Pierce, whose political machinations, along with the underlying conspiracy theory involving Shield’s compromise by rogue factions, mark out The Winter Soldier’s storyline as Marvel’s best.

References to future characters such as Dr Strange, callbacks to characters from across the Universe, Pulp Fiction and Community in-jokes, and a game-changing post-credits scene elevate the film to even further greatness.