Radiohead’s discography ranked

By Duncan Robertson

With the close of their long-awaited European tour, it is difficult to find a more apt occasion to recall the eclectic and endlessly beloved musical output of Radiohead. On social media, fans have expressed their appreciation for the choice of songs that made up their recent setlists, as the band chose to essentially “play the hits” from across their catalogue. Yet, unlike many groups of their generation, it is hard to find a list of tunes that so consistently challenge any notion of a genre-specific sound – which speaks to how continuously boundary pushing, ambitious and artistically broad Radiohead’s work is. Meeting at school and forming in the mid-80s, Radiohead have redefined alternative music whilst attaining both critical and commercial success over their lengthy career. Thus, ordering the group’s nine studio records from worst to best is a mighty feat, but one which I will attempt to undertake. 

Speaks to how continuously boundary pushing, ambitious and artistically broad Radiohead’s work is

9: Pablo Honey (1993) – 2/5

Perhaps the most unanimously agreed-upon fact surrounding Radiohead is the view that their debut, 1993’s Pablo Honey, is their weakest record. The album oozes with a sense that the group are attempting to find a musical footing but ultimately fail in the process. Whether it be the messy track listing, the often-uninspiring songwriting on tracks such as ‘Thinking About You’, and the generally uninteresting performances, this album leaves much to be desired. Nonetheless, it is hard to fault the songs which reflect the artistic potential the band went on to fulfil, with ‘You’, ‘Creep’ and ‘Blow Out’ being of particular quality. This album perhaps falls victim to being overshadowed by Radiohead’s later works which thoroughly outshine this humble debut, but overall, Pablo Honey is evidently the band’s poorest effort.

8: The King of Limbs (2011) – 3/5

Arguably Radiohead’s most ambitious work, The King of Limbs falls flat due to that very experimentation which makes it interesting, as it often comes at the expense of quality songwriting. From what the band throws at the wall, very little sticks, with much of the electronic eccentricities scattered across the track list feeling random and jarring. Despite this, aspects of the experimentation this record indulges in create a few fantastic products. For instance, the opening ‘Bloom’ with its whirlwind of layers and patterns and ‘Lotus Flower’ with its driving bass remain staples within the band’s catalogue and save this record from complete collapse. The King of Limbs followed a run of fantastic albums, and its attempts to meet the standards of those works, whilst commendable, showcase Radiohead perhaps biting off more than they can chew. 

7: Hail to the Thief (2003) – 4/5

Due to Radiohead’s consistent ability to produce excellent records, ranking their discography brings painful decisions. For instance, Hail to the Thief, a fantastic album, would rank highly on the average band’s discography, yet because of the group’s calibre of work, this album is the worst of the best. The major area which brings this work down is its somewhat forgettable songwriting: for every brilliant piece there are one or two uninteresting songs. These tracks, namely ‘I Will’ and ‘Scatterbrain‘, tend to circle around dull melodic motifs and have no resulting pay-off. However, this is not to say that the album is lacking in value. Some of the band’s most superb, well-produced and well-performed work falls on this record, such as the energetic opener ‘2+2=5’, the driving ‘Where I End and You Begin’, and the fuzzy crescendo ‘Myxomatosis’. Hail to the Thief is one of many classic albums that define Radiohead’s prolific catalogue, which, unfortunately, is brought down by a few dull spots in the tracklist. 

Due to Radiohead’s consistent ability to produce excellent records, ranking their discography brings painful decisions

6: A Moon Shaped Pool (2016) – 4/5

Another example of Radiohead’s ability to reinvent their sound, 2016’s A Moon Shaped Pool sees the band at their most ambient, folky and soft. The album’s indulgence into a chamber pop atmosphere combines seamlessly and subtly with the electronic inflections found across the track list. The acoustic textures on tracks such as ‘Desert Island Disk’ and ‘The Numbers’ create a lush soundscape, which contrasts flawlessly with the energy and synthetic fuzz of ‘Ful Stop’ and the pulsing groove of ‘Identikit’. Whilst the group excel in blending these countering styles, this record’s most virtuosic moments appear in the more sombre tunes. For instance, the deep, contemplative resonance of ‘Daydreaming’, ‘Glass Eyes’ and ‘True Love Waits’ excel in creating both a lush ambience and a devastating lyrical journey; these tracks have undoubtedly contributed to Radiohead’s reputation as being “depressing”. Nonetheless, this work is the band at their most poetic and melancholic, with Yorke’s vocal efforts taking on an understated and intimate tone. A Moon Shaped Pool exemplifies the band’s endless drive for artistic quality.

5: Amnesiac (2001) – 4/5

Often written off as a collection of Kid A B-sides, Amnesiac still holds its own as a quality work of experimentation and artistic boundary-pushing. There are few other albums in the band’s discography that make such forward-thinking reinterpretations of genre as this. The cold electronic inflections on tunes such as the opening, ‘Packt Like Sardines in a Crushd Tin Box’, and ‘Like Spinning Plates’ invent mechanical and surreal soundscapes. In terms of technicality, Amnesiac has endless offerings too, with the awkward patterns of ‘Pyramid Song’ and the experimental jazz arrangements seen in ‘Life in a Glass House’ evincing the group’s instrumental prowess. Whilst some tracks are less focused on experimentation, they still provide a high standard of quality. Namely, ‘I Might Be Wrong’ and ‘Knives Out’ stand out for their well-written guitar lines and atmospheric uniqueness, with ‘You and Whose Army?’ exemplifying the group’s dynamic and textural range. Whilst it could be argued that this track list is rather disjointed and sporadic, I feel it is the scattered attitude of this record which results in its distinctness and allure. In sum, Amnesiac deserves to be treated as one of Radiohead’s several classic releases, as the levels of creative ingenuity heard across this work combine to create an excellent product. 

In sum, Amnesiac deserves to be treated as one of Radiohead’s several classic releases

4: The Bends (1995) – 4/5 

Off the back of the mainstream success of Pablo Honey and Creep, 1995 saw the release of The Bends, an album which, whilst sustaining the palette of their debut, was the first true example of Radiohead’s artistic quality. The band took their major influences from before, namely the work of Pixies and R.E.M, and created an album of raw, 90s rock, definitive of the decade. That is not to say, however, that this record is in any way generic. Where the band resort to any form of popular formula, they find interesting ways of making the sound uniquely theirs. For instance, tracks such as ‘The Bends’, ‘Just’ and ‘My Iron Lung’, whilst some of the more commercially popular tunes on the record, push the envelope with their passion and structural identities. Equally, this album is not solely invested in noisy rock anthems. ‘Fake Plastic Trees’, ‘(Nice Dream)’ and ‘Bullet Proof … I Wish I Was’ are tunes that, for perhaps the first time in their catalogue, exemplify the sombre lyrical ability of Yorke and the melancholic atmosphere the band would go onto explore and perfect. There are few albums with a more consistent and tighter run of tracks as The Bends, which not only paved the way for Radiohead’s musical progression, but also proved their knack for balancing the dynamics of various moods. 

3: OK Computer (1997) – 5/5

1997’s OK Computer is largely regarded as Radiohead’s magnum opus. This was the first instance of the band truly pushing their sound into areas of experimentation, and in almost every instance, these developments reward mightily. Specifically, tunes such as ‘Paranoid Android’ show the band at their most technically, texturally and structurally proficient, with other original tunes, like ‘Subterranean Homesick Alien’ and ‘Exit Music (For a Film)’, creating spacy and vigorous auditory environments. The use of effects across the tracklist in creating an original soundscape are genius, yet the band also excel in generating catchy and perhaps more pop-centred tunes, reminiscent of their previous records. For instance, the mainstream hits ‘Karma Police’ and ‘No Surprises’ deserve all their received acclaim for their songwriting, and the distorted guitar lines of ‘Electioneering’ evince the band playing on and pushing the alternative rock sounds of The Bends. It is also necessary to note that this entire run of tracks results in Radiohead’s most cohesive and thematic project, as the dystopian and existential subjects that pervade the 53-minute runtime, which are microcosmically exemplified in the robotic lyrics of ‘Fitter Happier’, allow for a conceptual interpretation of the work. In every sense, this record is what defined Radiohead as much more than a stereotypical brit-pop alternative rock band, and it is clear to see why: the experimentation, songwriting and general boundlessness of the band’s approach makes for a wholly timeless work. 

2: Kid A (2000) – 5/5

Off the back of the critical success of OK Computer, creating an original an equally, or more, boundary-pushing album would seem an impossibility. Nonetheless, the turn of the millennium saw the turn of Radiohead to an even further height of experimental and sonic ingenuity. Specifically, 2000’s Kid A is by far the band’s most electronic and synthesiser-centred release, and the band push these computerised sounds to the absolute limits. From the outset, ‘Everything In Its Right Place’ is almost shockingly visceral in its difference to the band’s earlier work, with the cold atmosphere invented by the keys and reversed vocals creating an utterly original palette. These icy tones are furthered in tracks such as ‘Idioteque’, which boldly fuse hypnotic sine waves with a pulsing drum machine groove. Equally, other atmospheres are invented by the band on this record, such as the fuzzy bassline and the enveloping horn arrangements of ‘The National Anthem’ and the jazzy reverberations of ‘In Limbo’. The band and, in terms of lyrical themes, Yorke, touch upon their most melancholic nerves across this record. ‘How to Disappear Completely’ and ‘Motion Picture Soundtrack’ create oppressively haunting yet harmonic soundscapes which would go on to define the band. Whilst ‘Optimistic’ and ‘Morning Bell’ are perhaps less experimentally driven in comparison to other tunes, they excel in their songwriting and instrumental ambition. Overall, Kid A is thematically, atmospherically and musically Radiohead’s most forward-thinking and evocative effort to-date. 

The turn of the millennium saw the turn of Radiohead to an even further height of experimental and sonic ingenuity

1: In Rainbows (2007) – 5/5

2007’s In Rainbows is the ultimate culmination and best example of Radiohead’s artistic abilities. Since its release, the album has been heralded as one of the band’s most consistent and cohesive efforts, with every sound they had explored prior reaching true, balanced perfection on this track list. The band’s technical and electronic uniqueness is evidenced as soon the record begins, with the 5/4 crunching drum machines of ’15 Step’ reaching a blissful climax by the end of the song. Equally, the loudness of prior records is not left behind here: ‘Bodysnatchers’ presents a brilliantly written and brilliantly distorted guitar line which progresses through a dynamic structural underpinning. The group equally perfect their distinct skill for melancholic atmospheres, with tunes like ‘Nude’ and ‘Videotape’ being at once sublimely ethereal and devastatingly philosophical. The lush tones of these tunes are also echoes in ‘Weird Fishes / Arpeggi’ and ‘All I Need’, which not only create dream-like soundscapes with their looping guitars and reverb-induced instrumentation, but also both crescendo towards rewarding peaks. Perhaps, though, where this record truly reaches its artistic summit is in ‘Jigsaw Falling Into Place’, which, like some other tracks, is consistently building, but equally focuses on introspective, isolating lyricism, driving acoustic guitar performances and encircling, echoing vocal harmonies. There is no other album so rich on all fronts as In Rainbows, and it not only deserves the success it has seen but should be regarded as Radiohead’s best work. 

Featured image: Flickr