Racism within the Church is an institutional sin

By Dylan Brooks

Karl Barth describes the essence of the Church as “the event in which men are placed together before the fact of the reconciliation of the world, which has taken place in Jesus Christ and thus under the condemning grace and gracious judgement of God, that thereby they may be summoned to give thanks together and to love their neighbour to his praise”. Yet, all too often today, and throughout history, the Church fails at these theological commitments; the true togetherness of humanity and the eternal commitment to loving one’s neighbour.

[blockquote author=”” ]The plain reality of this situation is that a man wanted to serve the Church and was rejected from doing so because he is black[/blockquote]

This became evident once again when Augustine Tanner-Ihm, a black trainee vicar in the Church of England at Durham University, received a rejection to his application to become a curate because “the demographic of the parish is monochrome white working class, where you might feel uncomfortable”, as the email he received read. The email which he shared on Twitter also read that there was not a “sufficient “match”” between himself and the requirements of the post. The plain reality of this situation is that a man wanted to serve the Church and was rejected from doing so because he is black. The email he received even noted Augustine’s “obvious gifts”, but the Dioceses decided to judge him off the colour of his skin. The Dioceses has spoken and apologised to Augustine.

This horrible act of institutional racism is not an isolated event. The Rev Alwyn Pereira, who was born in Kenya and is of Indo-Portuguese heritage, was denied positions in the Diocese of Bristol because of, what an email about his job application described as, ‘cultural eccentricities’.

These two events show clear evidence of institutional racism within the Church of England.

Both events garnered attention after Bishops within the Church supported the Black Lives Matter movement. Archbishop of Canterbury Justin Welby renewed calls for action within the Church. Unfortunately, however, the combination of institutional racism in the Church and new sentiments show just how empty words are without proper action, especially from those in power.

[blockquote author=”” ]The Church also exists as a social body. It has a social role and social impact[/blockquote]

But how is the Church, what is meant to be the body of Christ, so infected institutionally with racism?

It must first be remembered that the Church is not good just by virtue of being the Church. The Church must continuously strive for justice and endlessly act in love; this includes anti-racism everywhere and at every level of the Church itself and society. It cannot accommodate racism.

Secondly, it must not be forgotten that the Church also exists as a social body. It has a social role and social impact. It is a shame that it appears this reminder is needed, but it means that the Church can be and is as racist as any other social institution. But this social body still holds the moral and spiritual duty to tackle racism within itself and the world. It should use its social position to tackle systemic racism everywhere in society including government, the police, and itself.

When the Church puts prejudices of humanity above all else, institutional racism is allowed to exist. When love is forgotten, judgements of man are held high, and theological commitments are lost, racism is allowed to roam.

[blockquote author=”” ]The Church can certainly be fully loving, but it must truly repent and address its racism[/blockquote]

With this all happening in the Church, Guli Francis-Dehqani, who is the bishop of Loughborough and is of Iranian heritage, has rightly called for transparency and a review into the systemic racism that exists within the Church’s structures. A thorough review will, as Bishop Francis-Dehqani expressed, expose the racism within the Church’s structures and allow the Church to begin to move into a future of justice and equality.

Yet this goes beyond the CofE institution. Members of its congregation, congregations of every denomination, and every denomination’s institution must be anti-racist to the maximum, as this is the call of love, justice, and togetherness. These sins of the Church have remained for too long. The Church can certainly be fully loving, but it must truly repent and address its racism. If it does not it runs the risk of further becoming what Dr. Rev. Martin Luther King Jr. described as “an irrelevant social club without moral or spiritual authority”.

This article is written in full solidarity and support of Augustine, Rev Alwyn Pereira, and anyone else who has been hurt by the Church.

Image: Billy Wilson via Flickr