Pygmalion review: “uplifting”

By Jessica Clark

Before seeing DUCT’s rendition of Pygmalion, I was an avid fan of Cameron Mackintosh’s musical My Fair Lady, and admittedly knew far less of George Bernard Shaw’s original play, written in 1912. Yet what this production lacked in chorus members, it more than compensated for with a punchy, humorous script and plot-line which simultaneously retained charm and resisted cliché.

The story of flower-girl and commoner Eliza (Elana Kaymer), who solicits the instruction of elocution teacher Henry Higgins (George Ellis), was brought to life with remarkable energy and commitment by all ten cast members, with stand-out performances from Ellis and Kaymer. Kaymer’s communication of Eliza’s transformation from “guttersnipe” into genteel lady demonstrated exceptional skill, not only in an unfalteringly accurate delivery of accent but also through her comedic utterances. Ellis’ portrayal of Higgins struck a satisfying balance between charismatic and exasperating, generating a feeling of ambivalence towards his character amongst the audience, which paved the way perfectly towards the drama’s ambiguous ending.

From its opening scene, the interplay between characters was compelling and well-staged. This pacey fluidity, however, was broken for a moment when Ellis required prompting – an opening-night blip which temporarily shattered the illusion of post-Victorian London. While onstage, actors worked hard with gestures and facial expressions, and all of their reactions to other characters were subtle, so all scenes were exciting to watch.

In a play so focussed on articulation, it was delightful to see such a variety of voices intoned successfully by the cast, ranging from the daintily enunciated register of upper-class tea-party-goers to the hefty grumble of Eliza’s good-for-nothing father (George Breare, who was on occasion guilty of slightly rushing his speech). Costume and set changes contributed towards the evening’s offering of escapism, evoking a world of bygone aristocracy. Particularly pleasing was Pygmalion’s fusion of light-hearted comedy with a sense of the intellectual, which could not have been achieved without the comedic timing which was particularly well-executed in dialogues between Higgins and Pickering (David Fairbairn).

Below the witticism lies a telling social commentary. In the programme, the producers’ (Lucy Brotherton, Beth Ismay, Kristina Grant) insist that “Eliza speaks to you all as clearly as if she was written yesterday,” and this certainly seems to be the case. Though the script is over a century old, the themes raised about snobbery and class struggle, as well as gender relations and a single woman’s fight for independence and self-assertion within society, offer messages still relevant to a modern audience. It is fascinating to consider how we, as students in the privileged environment of Durham University, can look at twenty-first century class divides and attitudes in light of Bernard Shaw’s exploration of social mobility, whose implications are universally pertinent while conveyed through humour.

Right before a set-change blackout towards the end of the play, a spotlight fell upon a statue prop in allusion to the play’s namesake –a Greek myth in which Pygmalion, a sculptor, falls in love with one of his statues, which then comes to life. This clever touch was a particularly notable example of director George Breare’s impressive attention to detail throughout the two-hour performance.

Without giving too much away, Pygmalion’s ending is not quite the same as Mackintosh’s happily-ever-after take on the tale, instead laden with more uncertainty. The final image of Higgins cackling semi-hysterically to himself was met with laughter by many audience members, which seemed a little misplaced given the scene’s tending towards the disturbing. Despite closing on this depiction of solitude, DUCT’s performance provided an overall uplifting evening, inlaid with the invitation to consider profounder aspects of social hierarchies, romantic relationships and the true meaning of gentility.

Photograph: Christie Clark

‘Pygmalion’ will run until Sat 5th Mar at the Durham City Theatre. Book your tickets here.