Pulling the trigger on trigger warnings?
By Mia Hyde
TW. Two letters. Trigger warnings bombard social media. It’s rare to stumble upon an Instagram post, Twitter thread, news article or even university lecture that isn’t prefaced by this bold, angry stamp. Born from an endeavour to render the internet a safer community for trauma victims, trigger warnings alert audiences that the specific content may elicit severely anxious responses. But are trigger warnings congenitally triggering?
By issuing TWs, authors can grant readers self-regulation of their emotional response. Individuals are able to regain control over their emotions and are able to choose whether to proceed with caution or wholly avoid the material. Far from 19th century dismissal of mental illness as spiritually induced or even fabricated, TWs speak for a culture more empathetic and who no longer stigmatise psychological conditions. Instead, PTSD and related anxiety disorders are now rightfully identified as colossally destructive, whereby trauma survivors and others affected are supported in recovery by initiatives such as TWs. Critically, TWs embody acknowledgement of the power which words hold over us – proving the archaic maxim “sticks and stones may break my bones, but words will never hurt me” fatally mistaken. Personally, TWs may have assisted my approach to some of the most emotionally devastating and scarring literature I have ever read (I’m looking at you, The Bell Jar and The Color Purple). So, perhaps TWs bring more help than harm. But how can anticipating and attempting to mitigate an extreme reaction cause harm? Well, let’s consider the possible outcomes of encountering a TW…
But how can anticipating and attempting to mitigate an extreme reaction cause harm?
Scenario A: Avoidance. Simply put, TWs fearmonger and deter readers. Yes, the individual is shielded from the potentially anxiety-inducing content, but this constitutes a crutch rather than a solution. The outcome? Denial and entrapment in a bubble of avoidance and anxiety. Exposure therapy is vital to CBT and rehabilitation, resting on the theory that avoidance consolidates the premise for negative beliefs – although, exposure ought to be undertaken according to the individual’s comfort. However, this is jeopardised by TWs. Taboo culture can be promoted by harnessing the necessary conversation about disturbing situations and content – survivor testimonies, for instance. Is this censorship? TWs can convince readers that this is inappropriate content, thereby circumventing free-will in steering reading choices. This evokes the bygone days of banning Lolita and Lady Chatterley’s Lover; social media is dictating what we view.
Scenario B: Access. You’re informed of some danger nestled inside the piece by the TW. Maybe you’re fine, you’ve prepared yourself for this. But fear acts irrationally, often hinging on expectation and imagination rather than the raw material. In practice, even individuals who would not otherwise experience abnormal anxiety are launched into subconscious questioning as to whether they should feel anxiety – all because of the trigger warning. Paradoxically, TWs could thus be undermining society’s mental health.
In practice, even individuals who would not otherwise experience abnormal anxiety are launched into subconscious questioning as to whether they should feel anxiety – all because of the trigger warning
Admittedly, it’s not quite so binary. Let’s consider this Scenario C: misused TWs. I confess, I’m no psychologist, but nor are the vast majority of those issuing TWs. What most misunderstand is that fear flouts logic. Triggers are highly idiosyncratic: not simply situations and words, but also scent, touch, audio – all of which depend on the individual. Things perhaps seemingly inert provoke acute distress in others; it is impossible for a publisher to predict what is ubiquitously triggering for audiences. This generalisation of triggers and anxiety arguably invalidates trauma victims who do not experience reactions to TW-ed content, or, antithetically, those who do experience reactions to material not TW-ed. I find it thereby irresponsible for non-professionals to assume responsibility to therapise others – and this raises further concern regarding legal culpability. If an article contains a TW, but psychologically damages a reader, is the publisher liable for harm wreaked on grounds of inadequate TWs? A trigger warning is a sizeable claim, so it’s reckless that they’re being thrown around whimsically.
So, TW: trigger warning, or a triggering phrase in itself? Undoubtedly, TW culture indicates a society wherein we’re more invested in our peers’ wellbeing. Nonetheless, it’s hardly fair to attempt to mind-read audiences and steer their emotions (essentially what TWs engineer). Content notes do offer an alternative: brief, small-print outlines of the material covered without any concrete claim for emotional triggers. Still, what’s imperative is that we, as a society, stop making assumptions about psychological disorders as linear and thus readily remediable. What mitigates stress and anxiety is unique to the individual, and ought to be devised through therapy under guidance of a professional psychiatrist – not by media moguls via rampant TW-ings.
Illustration: Elliar Cheung

