Protection of liberty: on security in Paris
By Sarah Thin
Much has already been written about the recent attacks in Paris – about horror and about heroism, about lost loved ones and simple acts of kindness, about solidarity and alienation, about the continuing fear, and the refusal to be afraid.
Just over a week later, we are beginning to witness France’s response to these terrible crimes. The state of emergency, originally declared on the night of the 13th of November, has been extended for three months by a law which was passed in only three days with almost unanimous approval from the French Parliament. This emergency regime allows, among other things, for the restriction of the freedom of movement, the implementation of curfews, censorship of the press, new police competences, and large increases of presidential power. Such measures are, however, apparently insufficient for President Hollande, who intends to modify the Constitution, so as to be able to introduce an even more protective regime which, according to him, will be better adapted to the current problems facing the State – for example, allowing the government and police greater powers for the monitoring and storing of internet communications and metadata. All in the name of ‘liberté, égalité, fraternité’.
Daily life changes subtly. Even miles away in my university town of Rouen, the new black-clad security guards stand at the doors to university buildings, refusing entry to frustrated students who left their student cards at home. I cannot tell if the ID checks, the bag checks and the increased police presence are supposed to make us feel more at ease, but if so they are failing miserably. Other parts of France are beginning to feel the effects of the emergency regime too: a mysterious curfew in Sens; hundreds of ‘assignations à résidence’ (similar to control orders in the UK); an unexplained raid on a family restaurant near Nice. The list goes on.
States of emergency such as this often go hand in hand with increased xenophobia and insularity. Fear reinforces group boundaries and divides peoples into ‘us’ and ‘them’ and it is human nature to blame those that do not reside on our side of that imaginary boundary line. We are seeing increasing calls to stop accepting refugees from the Middle East, not least from the Prime Minister, Manuel Valls. A number of the proposed anti-terrorism measures directly target those with dual nationality, including measures to remove French nationality from existing citizens, and to refuse such dual nationals from entering France “if they pose a risk to security”.
On the ground, a string of Islamophobic acts in the wake of the 13th of November have invoked fear of a new kind: the rise of racism and the extreme right. Despite the fact that the denial of the link between Islam and terrorism is repeated in the media, by people in the street, by experts and specialists, this denial tells its own story. Behind each of my lecturers’ repeated assertions that these attacks and murders have nothing to do with Islam, there is the whispered fear that this is something that needs to be said. It is the same pressure that makes Muslims worldwide feel the need to condemn attacks supposedly carried out in their name, and the anger of others that they should need to do so.
From the three drunk, hurt, and angry young men that blocked my way as I was getting off a night train in Paris this week, insisting that I must think they “worked for Daesh” because they were Muslim, to the Algerian exchange student who told me that for the first time since her arrival in France she no longer feels entirely safe, it is undeniable that despite the admirable chants of “liberté, égalité, fraternité,” such ideals are far removed from the reality for a lot of people.
The obvious fear for anyone familiar with French politics would be that such divisions are likely to play into the hands of the Front National, France’s nationalist, extreme right-wing party whose popularity has soared in the past decade. With regional elections approaching in December, there is a legitimate concern that they might make significant gains in the current political climate. Thankfully, recent polls are suggesting that this may not be the case. Hollande’s actions following the Paris attacks have been very popular: 91% of those interviewed approved of the new anti-terrorism measures, including the extension of the state of emergency, and 81% approved of the decision to intensify air strikes against Daesh. Hollande’s personal approval ratings have risen far faster than those of Marine le Pen, current leader of the Front National.
Despite the relief this brings, it does not change the fact that this approval stems from Hollande’s draconian response to the current crisis. Whether such measures of securitisation come from the Left or the Right, they are equally damaging and arguably counter-effective. Radicalisation in France has reached overwhelming levels, leaving police forces unable to deal with it. Nothing excuses the actions of those few individuals who decided to take up arms against hundreds of innocent people in bars, in cafés, in a concert hall, in a football stadium, but it is clear that this is a problem, and the current responses are not working.
There is no obvious solution for the problems facing France and the world with regard to terrorism. Nonetheless, it seems clear to me that deepening divisions and encouraging mistrust and suspicion between neighbours, colleagues, fellow bus passengers and students is not likely to lead to a safe, secure society. Calls for solidarity are fine if they do not alienate sections of the community. The attacks in Paris were an attack on a lifestyle and on a set of values. We, in our turn, cannot fight intolerance with intolerance. We cannot defend liberty by sacrificing it.
Image: aeneastudio via Flickr
