Private affairs should be just that

By Felicity Burgess

Along pavements of Parisian boulevards, above the noise of scooters and through the smoke of cigarettes there is one story that has been on everyone’s lips: French President François Hollande and his love affair with actress Julie Gayet. 

At least the idea of a national soap opera is what the headlines in Britain may have led you to believe, but here in the Paris nobody really cares. Yes, that is right, the French just do not care.

Had Cameron been caught between the sheets no doubt some would be calling for his resignation, whereas the polls in France show that the President of the Republic has in fact become more popular because suddenly the French are discovering he really is ‘normal,’ a cornerstone of his presidential campaign.

In Britain, we scrutinise, criticise and condemn our politicians so not one of them could come out of such a ‘scandal’ unscathed, yet the bankers in the city are able to snort cocaine without anyone batting an eyelid. And before you summon stereotypes of the liberal and scandalous French whose politics and culture are driven by romance and seduction think about what is actually at issue here.

Let us start by remembering Article 12 of the Declaration of Human Rights, “No one shall be subjected to arbitrary interference with his privacy.”

Surely, as President, Hollande has a responsibility to protect this right before his fellow citizens regardless of their professional occupation.

Yet his high-profile role has somehow made this seemingly unalienable right null and void. Remind me why exactly the President should be exempt from the right to a private life? Satisfying gluttony for a diet of gastronomic gossip simply does not suffice.

Satisfying gluttony for a diet of gastronomic gossip simply does not suffice.

At Hollande’s press conference cameras from around the world turned towards the Élysées, but were somewhat disappointed when only four questions delved under the covers towards the intimate. At this point you may choose to criticise a dormant French media who are incapable of formidable, investigative journalism.

While there is no denying that the liberty of the press is critically important in any thriving democracy, we must remember that the freedom of the press is not a passport for journalists to write whatever they fancy. They too have a duty; a duty to journalism.

Although many writers may choose to conveniently forget the “Declaration of the Duties and Rights of Journalists,” it is worth highlighting article 5 which states that “feeling obliged to respect the private life of people” is an “essential” duty of journalists in gathering, reporting on and commenting on events. Journalists, like professionals in every other field, also have a duty to respect the law, both written and ethical.

Of course the question of reconciling this legal obligation and the freedom of the press can be quickly resolved if we turn to the concept of overriding public need. This love affair is not about dozens of MPs who were squandering tax-payers money, nor is it about International Monetary Fund chiefs and their illegal prostitution rings. 

I cannot help thinking that cutting edge journalists should be motivated beyond sex, scandal and gossip.

Now correct me if I am wrong, but I see no need for us to know which woman Hollande kisses good night or who brings him his croissant in the morning.

I cannot help thinking that cutting edge journalists should be motivated beyond sex, scandal and gossip.

Only last year the Leveson Enquiry tried to teach the British the consequences of allowing Fleet Street beasts to roam wild and cause havoc. Unsurprisingly the French are scandalized by new levels of voyeurism and unethical journalistic practices that have come across the channel with the wave of aggressive paparazzi.

The French value the notion of a private life,  ‘private affairs are dealt with in private’.  Perhaps we would do well to respect that.

Et voilà, la real scandal!

Photograph: Cesar