President’s column: Higher tuition fees?

This week the Guardian Newsroom are kick-starting a debate that has been rumbling for a while. Vice Chancellors and Universities across the country are calling on the government to increase the amount they can charge for University education. Eric Thomas, Vice Chancellor of Bristol University says that “Politicians must bite the bullet and give universities the freedom to charge higher fees”.

That’s fighting talk, but there are plenty of people on the other side of the fence pointing out that a charge of £10,000 a year for university education will price many students out of the market. The suggestion of many VCs that individual institutions should be free to set their own fees is up for discussion when the government reviews the current system in 2009.

The lifting of the current £3145 cap would allow institutions to charge variable fees and mean that some, such as Durham, would be pitting themselves at the top of the market, whilst others would take more of an “economy value” approach. Faced with the choice of a degree that costs £3000, but is perhaps not as good as another that costs £10,000 but claims to be top of the range, which one would you choose? This supermarket approach to higher education strikes me and many others as a dangerous shift, and sets an irreversible precedent within the British education system.

Those arguing for variable fees suggest that extensive bursaries and schemes will help those whose parents cannot fund their education. We are to trust that this will amend the “national disgrace” that in 2003 Charles Clarke, former education minister who introduced top up fees, described as the social gap among those entering higher education. But I suspect that such a regressive policy will do the opposite. The fear of debt means that students will have to take the gamble and judge at the age of 17 whether or not they wish to commit themselves to decades of repayments: students won’t be choosing a degree based on what is best for them, but rather on the price tag attached. Allowing variable fees will cement a two-tier education system: those who can afford to will naturally pick the expensive universities, whilst middle-class students ineligible for bursaries will feel priced out of the market. In turn, universities at the top will struggle to remain academically elite.

National levels of debt are at an all time high and students are starting their working lives knee-deep in repayments. Next term DSU are launching a campaign that will feed into a national effort in the run-up to the Government’s 2009 review. We’ll be calculating the Durham debt and asking for your opinions so that by 2009 students nationally will be able to fight for a better, fairer system.