Prequels: compelling stories or lazy cash grabs?

By Nicholas Lemieux

With the recent back-to-back premieres of Amazon’s big-budget Rings of Power and HBO’s House of the Dragon, it is safe to say that prequels are an asset to studios more than ever. Whilst sequels run the risk of completely ruining their predecessor’s reputation by overriding their already-perfect endings, prequels with their vast scope of function act as a safe option for expanding franchises. They serve to promote the possibility of new characters and ideas with the added potential of developing already-established characters by further fleshing out their backstory. With that said, their fixed structure has also led them to receive harsh criticisms deriding their status as a cheap tactic to churn out pointless additions to an already-beloved franchise. Such divisive opinions therefore raise the question of whether prequels truly have the potential to rise above their usual corporate-mandated existence to fully enrich their predecessors.

Most infamous perhaps would be the various Star Wars prequels that have been subject to entirely mixed reception. Admittedly, the foundations on which the prequel trilogy was constructed showed immense potential: there are moments of brilliance in the compelling plotline of the moulding of the monster that is Darth Vader. Yet for all its good intentions, most of the prequels have entered widespread infamy for its weak execution of these ideas. As well as featuring particularly questionable writing (“I hate sand!”), the prequels struggled to stand alone and felt the need to indulge in pointless fanservice, answering questions no one was asking for. Were any fans genuinely clamouring to learn the origins of Han Solo’s name?

Prequels struggled to stand alone and felt the need to indulge in pointless fanservice

In addition, prequels must endure a tormenting balancing act between disparate fanbases: firstly, justifying its existence to long-term fans yet pleasing new viewers by ensuring they are not lost. The Sopranos prequel The Many Saints of Newark particularly struggled in this regard with the final product having a very muddled direction, unclear of how to accommodate viewers both old and not. Its continuity-heavy storyline packed with nods towards its parent show left newcomers completely clueless over what the story was, whilst fans felt disappointed by the fractured plot given that despite its marketing as a film dedicated to depicting the origins of Tony Soprano, he was hardly present. Through its middling execution, the movie failed to appeal to any sort of audience and serves as a cautionary tale of how not to go about creating a prequel.

That’s not to say however that prequels are completely incapable of rising against this stigma, especially when such projects are given the time to develop a story that organically fits within the franchise. The Godfather Part II for instance is heralded as one of the greatest sequels of all time and yet a significant chunk of its acclaim comes from its flashbacks to Vito Corleone’s rise to power. What could have been a lazy tactic to fill time, instead helps to enhance the franchise’s themes and worldbuilding. The prequel segments are perfectly implemented as a stirring parallel to Michael Corleone’s downfall and the jarring shift in tone, showing how the Corleone family shifted from loyalty to each other to loyalty to the business alone, adds to the tragic depth of the film and its predecessor.

An incredible achievement that takes full advantage of the ominous sense of inevitability associated with prequels

Personally, the chief example of a perfect prequel would be Better Call Saul, a show that excels in making its viewers completely revaluate the events of Breaking Bad whilst still maintaining its independence. Saul Goodman was originally intended to be one-note comic relief. However, the ease with which the prequel series deconstructs his character, questioning how such a soulless individual is created, juxtaposing his early days as honest Jimmy McGill, adds so many layers to what was once a throwaway character. Add in the plethora of iconic new characters to help the show carve out its own identity and you end up with an incredible achievement that takes full advantage of the ominous sense of inevitability associated with prequels to create a compelling story that serves as a powerful equal to its parent show.

The polarized reception that prequels rightfully receive is perfectly reflecting in the above-mentioned shows currently airing. Dragon seems to be successfully standing alone from its parent show (practically a blessing after Season eight…) and developing its own unique characters and lore, whilst Rings still seems to be floundering in its attempts to justify its existence beyond showing off its $1 billion budget. Ultimately, the optimist in me believes that every prequel has the potential to tell a compelling story if the writers can justify its existence both as a standalone entry as well as a companion. They’re harmless just so long as studios don’t go overboard by giving every fictional character a backstory, after all, who needs a Lion King prequel called Mufasa: The Lion King?

Illustration: Rosie Bromiley