Precarity presides as parliamentary crisis dooms yet another of Macron’s governments.

By Cully Tyan-O’Mahony

On 8th September, in a self-inflicted coup de grâce, François Bayrou became the first prime minister of France’s Fifth Republic to be removed through a confidence vote. Having called the vote, himself in a kamikaze move, intended to break the parliamentary impasse caused by his proposed budget. Roundly denigrated by opposition lawmakers, Mr Bayrou’s planned austerity measures, aimed at reducing a soaring public debt, would have seen the introduction of public service cuts to the tune of 44 billion euros. As well as infamously proposing to scrap two bank holidays. As such, only 194 of the National Assembly’s 577 deputies felt able to express confidence in Mr Bayrou and his government. This makes Mr Bayrou the second prime minister to be wrecked on the shore of attempted deficit reduction after his short-lived predecessor, Michel Barnier, failed to furnish parliament with a palatable budget last November.

As it stands, France’s public debt exceeds 3 trillion euros – 1 trillion of which is frequently, and controversially, attributed, by critics, to the low-tax, business-incentivising fiscal policies which Emmanuel Macron has adopted over his two presidential terms – whilst its budget deficit was at 5.8% of GDP last year. That’s 2.8 percentage points over the EU’s permitted deficit for member states, meaning it could be penalised as a result. The enormity of this task now seems even more pronounced in the wake of the decision on 12th September by Fitch – a major American credit rating agency – to cut France’s credit rating to an historical low. This will affect the government bond rates, as well as the interest at which the French government will be able to borrow money in the future.

Only 194 of the National Assembly’s 577 deputies felt able to express confidence in My Bayrou and his government

This urgency was not lost on Mr Macron, who acted with uncharacteristic haste in installing a new prime minister – the fifth in the space of three years – doing so within a day of Mr Bayrou’s fall. To take up this no-longer-so-illustrious mantle, Mr Macron chose Sébatien Lecornu, a member of his own parliamentary coalition La République En Marche. Many on the left will be dismayed by this decision, considering it a further affront to the left-wing Nouveau Front Populaire coalition which returned the greatest number of deputies in the 2024 legislative election. An indication of continuity in the direction of chaos. Certainly, it does nothing to confer any additional legitimacy on yet another pro-Macron minority government.

The political and personal proximity of Mr Lecornu to Mr Macron may well signal a last-ditch attempt to salvage the Renaissance political project after years of it being undermined by instability. With the leader of the far-right Rassemblement National (RN), Marianne Le Pen, branding the nomination of Mr Lecornu as “the final shot of Macronism”. Indeed, this appointment aligns with Mr Macron’s general strategy of appointing firm loyalists to enact his will in a divided parliament. The risk for Mr Macron is that by neglecting to pursue a more consensual politics he will only reinforce the image of dysfunctionality, and elitism, associated with the political mainstream. Thereby, strengthening the RN’s prospects for the 2027 presidential election.

However, the Elysée’s instruction for Mr Lecornu to meet with parliamentary colleagues from across the spectrum may suggest a subtle change of tact. For his part, Mr Lecornu has emphasised his “serious[ness]” in undertaking “frank” crossbench discussions. As well as the preclusion of any deal with the RN. He was quick to rule out the scrapping of two bank holidays, and to signal his intention to break with Mr Bayrou’s methods. The hope is that, by drawing the centre-left Socialist Party away from the broad-church NFP coalition with concessions over the degree of belt-tightening – a realisable budget will be able to pass the house.

The risk for Mr Macron is that by neglecting to pursue a more consensual politics he will only reinforce the image of dysfunctionality, and elitism

Yet, these conciliatory moves may still prove to be futilely piecemeal, considering the growing popular indignation against Mr Macron, personally, as well as against the Fifth Republic, institutionally. The hundreds of thousands who joined the Bloquons Tous protests, his record nadir in IPSOS opinion polls (17%), the recalcitrance of parliament, and the growing popularity of the extremes all act as a sign that the days of Mr Macron’s initially auspicious political project are numbered.

With major strikes scheduled to take place on 18th September, and potentially perturbed markets, it remains to be seen how Mr Lecornu will marry the two tasks of responding to the demands of the French people, while exercising fiscal responsibility to placate investors.

Image: Rama via Wikimedia commons