Pre-drinking: facing the extinction at the hands of the breathalyser
By Hannah Redman
It would be incredibly easy to critique this plan announced by the Safer Streets Scheme and Durham County Council in terms of its own stated aims. For example, suppose an individual has perfected the art of appearing sober when in fact they have consumed enough alcohol to be completely ‘smashed’ – how can the bouncer successfully identify they need to be breathalysed? Given that door staff have the authority to decide who to test or not, how can the council guarantee that racial and gender-based prejudices will not play even a small part in the largely unregulated decision-making process of this scheme?
As members of the public, we are also not privy to the numerical limits the council has decided is too much alcohol to consume on a night out. Presumably this compact breathalyser device does not have the capacity to take biological factors such as height and weight into the equation either; science unequivocally highlights the impact of these factors on how well an individual can cope with the amount of alcohol they consume. Given the behaviour of intoxicated individuals is driving this social initiative, it is surprising such integral details have seemingly been overlooked by its architects.
However, I believe this policy represents a broader shift in this country: a dangerous shift towards ‘nanny-state’ politics
However, I believe this policy represents a broader shift in this country: a dangerous shift towards ‘nanny-state’ politics. Why does the council not believe we, as adults, are capable of understanding what our individual bodily limits are when it comes to alcohol tolerance? We are not deciding to drive a car, but deciding to enjoy a social experience with friends, in a hospitality space which thrives on the heady mix of individuals unburdened by the couple of drinks they’ve had before arriving there. Perhaps, underneath the noble aims of helping people keep themselves safe on a night out, tackling spiking incidents might be a better place to start – there are darker forces at play.
It hardly seems a large leap of logic to assume Durham clubs will benefit financially from this breathalyser scheme: clubbers will not want to risk being turned away at the door, so will drink less, and then have to buy more drinks in the club to have the experience they want on a night out. It is troubling to think students with less disposable income may be priced out of the clubbing scene. Pre-drinking is a British institution, facing extinction at the hands of the breathalyser.
Photography: Thomas Tomlinson

