Practice, preparation, and the unexpected: the reality of human spaceflight
By Thomas Jenkins
It’s been said many times before. Space is hard, human spaceflight is harder. And for the recent return of NASA astronauts Butch Wilmore and Suni Williams, this is no exception. Papers descended onto the spectacle that, two of NASA’s most experienced astronauts have been stranded in space; their 8-day mission turned to 9 months. Responsible, was their spacecraft – the Boeing Starliner – it had previously flown uncrewed to the International Space Station (ISS), and once more before that (although that time, it failed to reach the ISS). It’s a spacecraft plagued with thruster failures which are responsible for controlling the Starliner in orbit; and this being its first crewed test flight it was almost inevitable: something had to go wrong. NASA will have been well aware of this, and clearly they were, sending just two of their most experienced and well-flown astronauts in a seven-person capacity spacecraft. So, what goes into this preparation for a test flight that probably will go wrong?
This isn’t the first time NASA has had a problem in space, back in 1970 an oxygen tank ruptured on a crewed spacecraft, leaving the three men aboard without heating, cooling, water, oxygen, carbon dioxide filtration systems and navigation. The list goes on, bearing in mind most equipment had at least one duplicate for redundancy. At times, the crew relied upon mechanical wristwatches, a sextant and their steady hands to fly. Now it’s been turned into a film, Apollo 13 (no, Tom Hanks was not the commander of the real mission). Even back then, safety was paramount, something that the international community has only built on to this day.

Nowadays, human spaceflight operations are confined to Low Earth Orbit (LEO) where it takes 45 minutes to get back down onto Earth, spacecraft are safer and we now have safe outposts – the ISS and China’s Tiangong space station – in LEO. Space is also governed by the UN Outer Space Treaty, which effectively treats spacecraft as ships are treated in International Maritime Law – ships must come to the aid of another if in distress. Wilmore and Williams were always going to have help at hand.
The major issue was the highly complex logistical nightmare of keeping the two on the ISS. Missions, cargo and astronauts are often planned years in advance, so the unexpectedly long duration stay of the astronauts will have given mission planners a headache; at times the total crew staying on the ISS reached 12. Re-supply craft were rescheduled, packed with more food and water all while trying to cram in as much science equipment as possible. However, this must have been a welcome rest for the crew already aboard the ISS, having two more experienced astronauts to help with experiments, cleaning (it’s said to smell like a gym) and other tasks, which are planned to the nearest minute. In fact, Williams took command of the outpost and even performed her 9th spacewalk making her the 4th most experienced spacewalker in history, calling space her, “happy place”.
Now, both are back on terra firma, having returned in one of Elon Musk’s Dragon spacecraft, something again that NASA was ready for. Even though neither had had any training on that craft, both having flown at least 2 types of craft before, NASA will have picked them based on that experience too in anticipation of a return not on the Starliner.
It seems it paid to have the experience and skills; look no further than Durham’s own Dr Rosemary Coogan, the UK’s 3rd astronaut, undertaking her years of training and preparation for missions like this
It seems it paid to have the experience and skills; look no further than Durham’s own Dr Rosemary Coogan, the UK’s 3rd astronaut, undertaking her years of training and preparation for missions like this. Every failure is practiced again and again until the procedure becomes second nature, astronauts really do sweat the small stuff, and only then are considered for flight.
So, to answer our earlier question: what preparation goes into these kind of flights? It’s all about practice and experience, something that the space industry has known for decades. For Wilmore and Williams, this preparation also comes with a sense of familiarity — whether aboard the ISS or back on Earth.
Image: NASA Public Domain via Wikimedia Commons

