Populist leaders see ill health as a weakness
By Joseph Monaghan
The Fisher King is a character from Arthurian legend. He is the last of a long line of monarchs, who through a terrible injury has become unable to do anything but fish in a small boat by his castle. As he sits there, fishing away, his country turns to a wasteland, and when he is eventually healed, the land heals too. In the context of the 12th century, when this tale first appears, the message to those who were listening is clear: the King must be strong, for the health of the King is the health of the nation.
The few kings of today no longer rule; in their place are political leaders, a not insignificant number of whom have caught Covid-19 this year. Among their number are our Prime Minister, Brazilian President Jair Bolsonaro, and, most recently, Donald Trump. Their response to their infection has been very interesting and provides a rare, honest insight into the mind of the populist leader of the 21st century.
leaders cannot see past their deeply personal attitudes to being sick
It’s not a new thing for politicians to minimise or try to hide illness. Politicians with significantly different worldviews to the trio above have hidden their afflictions – JFK had Addison’s disease, as well as regular back pain, fevers, and adrenal problems, all of which were only made known to the pub- lic years after his death. Another American President, Franklin D. Roosevelt, was unable to move about without use of a wheelchair, yet carefully choreographed public appearances to avoid showing him going to and from podiums or balconies which he could stand at. The Secret Service even destroyed photos of the President being moved around by others.
It was a different time, however, when disabilities and weakness were discriminated against more severely; surely in our time, people are less judgemental of such things? In today’s politics, where relatability and being a ‘man of the people’ are priceless qualities for anyone facing the prospect of an election, it could seem that getting ill could be a good thing – suffering with the people, living through what they’re living through, all being in this together.
Power is the key here, as well as wanting to appear powerful
Yet, leaders have instead sought desperately to downplay their illness; we were told that Johnson was in ‘good spirits’ on the 5th of April as he was being moved to hospital as a ‘precautionary measure’, yet days later he was in intensive care. Trump’s hospital stay has borne out in a similar way, with him ‘feeling well’ on his first day, despite running a high fever – a detail that was only made available to the public after he returned to the White House.
So why the disconnect? Instead of seeing the political advantages it could confer, these leaders cannot see past their deeply personal attitudes to being sick. Illness is something that these people hate; biographies and accounts of both Johnson and Trump speak of how they cannot stand being ill, but what they really can’t deal with is appearing ill. They identify it with a personal weakness, a failure.
We were told throughout Johnson’s illness that he was working through government business when in reality he was gasping for air, and how he’d get through it because he was a ‘fighter’. The projection of personal power and strength was more important than showing what they would see as vulnerability, and what most would instead call humanity.
populist leaders of today don’t really want to be elected leaders
Power is the key here, as well as wanting to appear powerful. Indeed, the closest thing that any of these administrations have to a guiding ideology is becoming powerful. All of them have valued the loyalty of their ministers over their competence; all of them have an unwillingness to engage with the legislative bodies they govern alongside; all of them have pursued a programme of more executive authority, especially over the permanent institutions of their countries.
The populist leaders of today don’t really want to be elected leaders, not deep down: they don’t literally want to be kings, but in some way they can’t help but want to be like one – powerful, strong, indomitable. They can’t accept being ill, because in their mind they’re doing a fantastic job – they’re getting Brexit done, they’re building back better, they’re making America great again – and doing a fantastic job and being ill cannot be true at the same time. After all, the health of the King is the health of the nation.
Feature image by DonkeyHotey. Available via Flickr.
