Politicians must not collude in panicky immigration policy

 immigration 2

by David Siesage

It seems that UKIP’s influence is spreading. This month all the major political party leaders have come forward to discuss the thorny issue of the immigration ‘problem’, each proposing a raft of restrictions on benefits and freedoms afforded to foreign visitors, albeit with caveats acknowledging the ‘good work’ immigration has done.

Ed Miliband has apologised for mistakes made by his predecessors, and Yvette Cooper has outlined a series of proposals to restrict immigrant access to benefits and public services, with bans on new migrants claiming jobseeker’s allowance and sending benefit money to their families abroad. These are policies they insist are not a regurgitation of Gordon Brown’s doomed ‘British jobs for British workers’ pledge.

Nick Clegg, too, added the finishing touches to what the Liberal Democrat Voice website call his ‘illiberal hat-trick’, alongside secret courts and press regulation, with a proposal to charge visitors from ‘high-risk’ countries a £1,000 bond – described by former Labour immigration minister Keith Vaz as “unworkable, impractical” and “discriminatory” – alongside yet more talk of ‘good’ and ‘bad’ immigrants. A rather surprising U-turn for a politician who was pledging to grant amnesty to illegal immigrants before the coalition…

The unholy trinity is completed with David Cameron, who outlined his ‘tough’ stance on immigration, intending to keep immigrant families off council housing waiting lists for their first five years in the country, restrict their NHS access, and revoke jobseeker’s allowance after six months if they are not shown to be seeking work sufficiently actively.

Downing Street were forced to defend Cameron’s speech soon after, claiming that it was an attempt to “reduce pull factors” to Britain, thus reducing the potential immigration spike in January 2014 when Bulgaria and Romania gain access to the full freedom of movement benefits of EU membership – a worrying reminder of the proposed ‘Why You Shouldn’t Come to Britain’ advertising campaign.

With all the political drivel spilled about immigration of late, it would be easy to start to believe the consistent theme: immigrants are work-shy benefit scroungers, and they need to be stopped.

With all the political drivel spilled about immigration of late, it would be easy to start to believe the consistent theme: immigrants are work-shy benefit scroungers, and they need to be stopped.

However, this is nothing but toxic political rhetoric, cooked up as a result of events in Eastleigh. Like many policy decisions, this is simply an election ploy, not based on party ideology or any coherent strategy.  A by-election second place for the nationalist party has sent shivers down the spines of the traditional political elite. Suddenly, not to appear ‘tough’ on immigration is considered political suicide. Indeed, one could not be blamed for thinking that Nigel Farage has personally influenced the policies of the three main political parties in this regard; UKIP must be delighted with the proliferation of their principal ideology by the political heavyweights.

This frightfully knee-jerk reaction to the appearance of even the slightest glimmer of a challenge to the political status quo is worrying, especially when the reality of the immigration situation is largely at odds with new proposals. It is clear that unchecked immigration is unsustainable and sometimes damaging, but leaving aside the fact that restriction of immigrant benefits is a murky area in EU law, the populist immigration dialogue is largely devoid of fact.

Benefit tourism is minority sport, if not a myth entirely. Indeed, immigrants are more likely to be in work and contributing to the public purse than so-called ‘native’ Britons. The UCL Centre for Research and Analysis of Migration even found that in 2008/9, Eastern European workers contributed £1.37 in taxes for every £1 of public services they utilised – 52p to the pound more than native Britons. At the same time, immigrant workers represent around 13% of the workforce, whilst only accounting for 7% of benefit claimants. Indeed, despite the populist rhetoric, immigrant workers actually bolster the welfare system. Immigrants must not be a political scapegoat for our poor economy.

farageFurthermore, demonising legitimate immigrants, and making them out to be scroungers, undermines entirely their general hard work and importance to the British economy. As Prince Philip so quaintly/offensively alluded to earlier this year, migrant workers contribute greatly to British life, making up a large number of the public service workers. Clegg even alluded to this in his speech, saying that “… if every member of an immigrant community suddenly downed tools … The NHS would fall over.”

Douglas Murray claimed that Cameron’s speech could be summarised in one sentence: “mass migration has brought some good things, but it has also brought problems so here is some tinkering we propose.” However, Cameron’s speech was much less a case of empty political rhetoric, than one of yet more ill thought-out, pressurised policy making; populist gutter politics.

The Tories do not need to jump to the right to resuscitate their grass roots support.  The Conservative candidate in Eastleigh was considerably right-wing, and took a strong stance on immigration. Yet she was crushed by the UKIP candidate. Eastleigh has shown that the electorate either vote for UKIP or they vote for sanity, but as the sane parties desperately try to replicate UKIP, voters could seek solace and consistency in Farage’s arms.

It goes without saying that our current immigration system has its flaws, and they should be addressed with considered, careful policies, along with a new, more competent institution to manage it. However, more than this, it goes without saying that our government and their opposition should not be bullied into ill-conceived political tinkering by a nationalist party who boast a grand total of zero MPs. In a month that has also seen worrying controls imposed on an unsupportive press, tri-party consensus has not smothered the political classes in glory.

What do you think? Has immigration gone too far? Or should we welcome it? Tweet your reactions to @PalatiComment.

Photograph: Christopher Hilton