Policy for relationships would be outdated

By Ellen Orange

A recent Telegraph report has revealed that relationship breakdown in the UK is now costing the Government £50 billion a year. This has sparked calls from politicians and organisations to tackle the issue in the name of economic recovery. But to what extent should the government be involved in this? In 21st Century Britain what place does government policy on relationships have?

There has been a concern over the last decade that the low marriage and high divorce rates are creating unstable and dysfunctional families, which many see as the cause of a number of social problems in the UK. Now we are hearing that this has repercussions economically as well. We all know the government will be concerned with such a large figure, which has been on the increase in recent years. Furthermore, with this figure amounting to £1,500 a year per taxpayer, policies to reduce the cost may be appealing to voters.

"any policy on this would spark severe criticism for being old fashioned, and discriminative to those who would prefer another type of relationship or family"
A traditional family is not necessarily for everyone 

Amongst the calls, a ‘National Relationship Strategy’ has been suggested, and for the government to provide help during ‘transition points’ such as marriage and retirement. There has been no report about what this relationship strategy would entail, but following suit form the tax breaks for married couples, it would be likely to promote marriage and the traditional nuclear family as a stable environment for children to grow up in.

But would this fall on deaf ears? Today we don’t view marriage in the same way as we once did. Many people don’t want to get married for various reasons– religious ones for example, as well as views that the institution of marriage carries a legacy of inequality. Never mind the fact that some people just cannot afford a traditional wedding. Like the tax breaks for married couples, would this be another discriminative policy? How do we factor civil partnerships and homosexual relationships into this? There are still some who would argue that this doesn’t count as a stable environment.

There are endless questions like this when we come to think about the different varieties of family we see in today’s Britain. And encouraging marriage doesn’t guarantee it will last.

So, furthermore, how would this strategy treat divorce? As nothing has been suggested we can only speculate, but would it be right for the government to discourage this? We now see divorce as a right, but moreover what would be the cost if obtaining a divorce was once again difficult, or looked down upon? We would be creating far more dysfunctional households with children who were subject to arguing parents, or partners who suffered from abuse who would struggle to leave. But even before this speculation, would it work?

After decades of not marrying and divorce being ‘normal’, would a strategy put in place by the government really be effective? Therefore how much money would really be saved? Or would they simply be spending more to no avail?

We can also question the degree to which people want the government to be involved in their lives. Help at transition points may actually be useful for some, depending on what form this comes in.

But the intrusion of the government telling them how to cope with things that they have previously dealt with themselves might be considered a wasted effort. And what can the government tell us about marriage or retirement that we can’t look up on the Internet, or speak to friends, family or even a professional about?

what can the government tell us about marriage or retirement that we can’t look up on the Internet, or speak to friends, family or even a professional about?

Yes, the cost of relationship breakdown is high. But in modern society we see the ability for an unstable relationship to break down as a right. Many still do get married, or enter a civil partnership and stay together, sustaining perfectly stable and productive lives, but encouraging this for those who don’t is regressive and futile.

And yet, reports such as this fail to consider that relationship breakdown may be positive; in some instances it produces more stable families, free from emotional distress, and even a bigger support network for children.

It is clear that any policy on this would spark severe criticism for being old fashioned, and discriminative to those who would prefer another type of relationship or family, or to remain single. Financially we see that the cost is high, but even if those schemes were effective, would it be worth it to reduce the cost to the state slightly? We treasure our right to make our own decisions about our personal relationships, and the government needs to find a solution that does not threaten this.

Photograph: Royal BC Museum