Police, residents and staff concerned by students’ drinking
In the wake of the DSU Alcohol Awareness Week, Palatinate investigates the effects alcohol is having on student behaviour in Durham city centre
Stood on the Bailey at 11pm on a Wednesday evening, it is easy to question Durham’s reputation for producing the movers and shakers of tomorrow. As students pile out of college bars, they leave behind them a trail of smashed bottles, piles of vomit and takeaway packages. Reaching the cathedral, one male stops to urinate against a parked car. His friends continue, pausing to watch another male attempt to drink an entire bottle of white wine before beginning the descent into the city centre.
At a time when student conduct across the UK is gaining national media attention, how typical is such behaviour of the average Durhamite? Local residents, University staff and the police have raised concerns that Michaelmas 2009 was the worst term on record for alcohol-related offences. Is this a case of a minority of repeat offenders tarnishing the reputation of the majority, or are more students becoming involved in disorderly behaviour in the city?
In November 2009, commercially organised drinking sessions were condemned after Sheffield Hallam student Philip Laing was caught on CCTV urinating over a war memorial. Public outcry followed the incident, with judge Anthony Browne attacking the drink culture prevalent in UK universities.
January of this year saw the issue return to prominence, as the BBC and others reported on ‘Hitler – The Drinking Game’, a Facebook group owned by two students from Huddersfield University. Sky News used its website to shame those who had uploaded photographs to the page depicting themselves taking part in the Holocaust-themed game. With players required to make Nazi salutes and interrogate others, the group was immediately condemned by politicians and war veterans.
Between January 24th and 31st, Durham Students’ Union (DSU) promoted Alcohol Awareness Week. Events were organised by welfare representatives from colleges across the University, in the hope of ensuring students were aware of the damaging effects of alcohol consumption. However, campaigns centred on the health implications of binge drinking, largely leaving out the effect had by alcohol on group behaviour in the city.
DSU President Natalie Crisp remains adamant that the Union is doing all it can to promote responsible and safe drinking. She argued that many college bars and city centre premises now take part in ‘Best Bar None’ – a national programme aimed at minimising alcohol-related crimes and promoting a safe night time environment for pub-goers. The scheme encourages licence holders to take practical measures to ensure good behaviour, including providing plastic drinking glasses later on in the evening and avoiding drinks promotions which encourage binge drinking.
Despite these efforts, the Durham City Police Constabulary continues to receive complaints from local residents and bar owners regarding incidents involving students and alcohol. University Liaison Officer Philip Raine works with the community groups, the DSU and senior University figures to monitor student conduct. “I would say, broadly, we have had more complaints since October. Although we always get a lot in the first term, they have been more concentrated in certain areas”.
Whilst Mr Raine recognised that there was always likely to be a degree of misconduct, he was sure of the line between boisterous behaviour and criminal damage. “We know that if we leave traffic cones out in freshers’ week, they will disappear. But we have recently had reports of students walking over cars, damaging important traffic barriers and making excessive amounts of noise. We can deal with the minor offences, but anything more than that is down to a lack of respect”.
The DSU recognises the importance of communication between students and local residents in ensuring a good relationship is maintained. The Livers Out Officer system is designed to allow information coming from community groups to reach students via JCR e-mails and talks. But whilst this system might be effective in raising awareness around burglaries and car thefts, it seems less able to deal with the wider tensions between locals and students.
DSU Livers Out Officer David Morris is responsible for ensuring that communication with JCRs remains effective and consistent. “In general, residents are aware of the good work done by students. They recognise that the community is made more vibrant and prosperous by the University. But at the moment, there are times when the complaints of residents are being heard above those things”.
Indeed, Ms Crisp was keen to highlight the ways in which students integrate well into the local community. “Student Community Action (SCA) places over 200 volunteers on projects around the Durham area. Last year, Durham Universities Charities Kommittee (DUCK) raised over £500,000 for charity. A large proportion of this went to local causes such as the Butterwick Hospice and the Weardale Mountain Rescue Team”.
Mr Raine believes that tensions within the city centre could be more to do with societal problems than the conflicting arguments pressed by student representatives and local groups. “Durham has a lot of history. We’re surrounded by old mining villages, and we’ve got a lot of people using the city who are actually from other places”. For the police, the mutual resentment between those from the County Durham area and students arriving in the north from other areas of the country is an age-old problem.
It is clear that the University and the police face challenges in measuring trends in student behaviour. Whilst colleges can deal effectively with internal incidents of misconduct, the police face greater challenges in ensuring offenders receive adequate punishment. Local patrols don’t have the resources to log and pursue every alcohol-related incident. With most minor incidents receiving only a verbal caution, it is difficult to monitor repeat offenders or specific groups of troublemakers.
At 9am on a Thursday morning, a member of staff from the University Estates and Buildings department is making his usual rounds. Reaching Palace Green, he parks his van in the Castle corner and takes out a roll of bin bags. By the time he returns, he’ll have filled two bags with empty wine and beer bottles, takeaway boxes and other litter. Before he leaves, I ask him if he normally finds so much. “Only in term time” he laughs. “It’s the students that give me something to do up here. If it wasn’t for them I’d have an extra hour in bed each day”.
