Pogacar the GOAT?
By James Jones
On Saturday, Tadej Pogacar broke away from the peloton with 50 kilometres and secured his fourth consecutive Il Lombardia, and 25th victory in the 2024 season. 2024 has been a remarkable year for PogaÄŤar, having claimed his 3rd Tour de France, a debut Giro d’Italia and the UCI World Championship – cycling’s triple crown. The Slovenian currently holds enough ranking points by himself that he would be in the top 10 of the UCI team rankings. Such a momentous season has transformed the debate around Pogacar’s status in the history of the sport, from whether he could provide competition for Eddy Merckx for the title of the greatest cyclist of all time, to whether he has already surpassed Merckx altogether.
At first glance, a straightforward comparison between Merckx and PogaÄŤar would initially suggest that the Slovenian still has a fair way to go to merit such a conversation. Merckx has an unrivalled 11 Grand Tour wins to PogaÄŤar’s 4 (which doesn’t even include La Vuelta), has won all 5 monuments – the most prestigious one day races in road cycling – twice over (with PogaÄŤar yet to win all of them) and has won virtually every major race at least once. In a straight shoot-out between on-paper achievements, Merckx wins. No question. But the reason behind this debate stems from the nature of PogaÄŤar’s victories.
The staggering solo breakaway at Il Lombardia is nothing new for regular viewers of road cycling, yet that doesn’t diminish the sheer disbelief we feel watching. Pogačar has made dragging a seemingly impossible solo breakaway to a victory the routine of almost every race he enters. Two other monuments, L-B-L and the Stade Bianchi both saw Pogačar race away from the pack unaccompanied. Finishing off the triple crown in Zurich just a few weeks ago, Pogačar steamed away from his main rivals Remco Evenepoel and Mathieu van de Poel with over a third of the 270 km race still to go, in a ride that Merckx himself acknowledged surpassed anything he had achieved at the World Championships.
It’s impossible to talk about Pogačar’s achievements without the overarching context of his rivalry with the other great cyclist of the new generation: Jonas Vingegaard
It’s impossible to talk about PogaÄŤar’s achievements without the overarching context of his rivalry with the other great cyclist of the new generation: Jonas Vingegaard. Since toppling PogaÄŤar’s compatriot Primoz Roglic as the main man at Visma LAB (then Jumbo) in 2020, Vingegaard has had the upper hand in Grand Tour racing by epitomising everything that PogaÄŤar is not. His calculated style is often maligned by the cycling community, particularly in contrast to the occasional erratic, spontaneous style of PogaÄŤar. Whatever your thoughts on Vingegaard’s style, the fact remains that he is the only rider in 2024 to have closed down PogaÄŤar and beat him to a stage win. That he even lined up to start this year’s Tour, having suffered a punctured lung and multiple rib fractures in the Basque country just 3 months beforehand is easily the most remarkable story of the season. In my view, this incident adds a significant asterisk to the results of the latest edition of Le Tour.
So is Pogačar the GOAT of road cycling? I would be hesitant to award him that accolade while he is still so early in his career. At only 26, Pogacar could have at least another 5 years at the peaks of his powers to add to his already impressive array of titles. With the 2025 season kicking off in mid-January, the most pressing questions viewers have are sure to be answered. Can Pogi sustain this otherworldly level of form, or will a fully fit and motivated Vingegaard roar back at Le Tour and draw level once again? Can Remco Evenepoel continue his remarkable ascendancy to be able to properly compete at the Tour, providing not just a respectable 3rd place but a genuine challenge? Whatever happens over the next few years, we can guarantee one thing: that we won’t be short of entertainment.
Image: Hugo LUC via Wikimedia Commons

