Please think before you blog

Newspaper sales are plummeting in both the UK and the USA. With the Internet offering free, fast access to news and comment, fewer and fewer people in our manic world have the time, or indeed the patience and inclination to sit down with a newspaper. Palatinate recently launched its new blog offering blogging as a potential replacement or augmentation of the traditional newspaper column. “Bloggers will save you” says Chris Wright, “well, perhaps not, but they can’t hurt”. Is this ‘they can’t hurt’ attitude to the blog as reasonable as it sounds, or is the blog in fact a far more dangerous entity than we had previously recognised?

Blogs, according to Andrew Sullivan, a pioneer of the Internet blog, allow the writer to present something unique: “the spontaneous expression of instant thought”. Unlike newspaper columns which come after a period of thought and consideration, the blog is an author’s opinion published moments after it has been written, often moments after it has been formed. Such spontaneity, the evocation of the imperfection of thought, has been sought by authors for centuries and the blog, Sullivan argues, allows the writer to experience this. The expression of a mind at a given time is indeed a fascinating phenomenon, available momentarily and then lost forever. However to claim that this is a suitable medium for discussion of important topics such as politics or the economy is misguided.

A newspaper column, like a news report, comes as a result of careful thought by an expert upon a particular issue, subject to editorial controls and, often rigorous legal and factual checks. A blog is self-publishable by anyone with an Internet connection and is subject to the author’s personal degree of self-interrogation alone. A person’s immediate thoughts on a particular issue are often reactionary and ill-thought-out, later a source of shame; blogging allows a person to publish such thoughts and encourages others to read them as an informed opinion. Sullivan would argue that the process of blogging allows the author to return to the subject later and amend his previous errors in a new blog or to apologise in the event of factual errors. However, in a hectic world where people don’t have time to read the newspaper, who has time to return to a blog possibly (in Sullivan’s case) several times a day to see how their opinion has changed? Very few people. So the majority, rather than seeing the evolution of the mind, instead see a mere first impression. Even those who do have time to read a second or even third blog on the same topic by the same author will often be most moved by the first impression, which tends to have the biggest impact. Thus, if someone were to form an opinion on a matter based solely on the arguments of blogs, they could end up wholly misled as to the true nature of said matter.

Many have hailed the advent of blogging and the ability to post music and film on the Internet as a democratisation of talent, removing art from the domain of big business and allowing anyone’s raw talent to shine through. Whilst there is some truth to this argument, particularly in the music business, there is however a danger of the Internet fostering a cult of the amateur which will see the creative class lose out.

Bloggers are mostly unpaid amateurs who post out of their own interest. In contrast, newspaper, television and radio journalists make a career from their work and are paid in accordance. If the current trend away from traditional journalism continues until it is no longer profitable then the creative class will be forced to look elsewhere for work.

This harms the public as well as the journalist, as expensive forms of journalism such as reports from war zones will no longer be viable, placing the government under less scrutiny and allowing them to continue unchecked. There are, of course, professional bloggers, such as Sullivan himself, but these people are often concurrently writers for newspapers or broadcast journalists.

I do not mean to suggest that blogging should be abolished; it can be an entertaining and informative medium. However, fields such as politics and economics are of vast importance and hence require expertise and consideration. Most blogs do not offer these, instead offering a highly stylized, conversational view of a given topic at a given time.

Professional journalism is necessary and valuable; newspaper columnists and broadcast experts rise to the top of their fields because of talent, knowledge and expertise. Their career involves seeking the truth.

In contrast, anyone can write a blog, anonymously if they so wish. Allegations such as “Obama is a Muslim” can be made anonymously by a blogger, whereas traditional journalists are subject to editorial and legal controls.

Where blogging is valuable is in allowing the voices which represent experience different to our own, to be heard. For instance, BBC Radio 4’s Nick Clarke wrote a fine blog detailing his fight with cancer. Many of us have no idea of the thoughts and feelings of a cancer sufferer and a blog allows them to detail the evolution of such emotions over a period of months. Blogging should be valued and praised for its merits but we must remain cautious of its dangers and shortcomings, and continue to give precedent to traditional journalism or we risk undermining a pillar of democracy.

palatinate.org.uk/category/blog